Cost-effectiveness of Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Cervical Clearance of Obtunded Blunt Trauma After a Normal Computed Tomographic Finding
Authors:
- 1 July 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA Surgery
- Vol. 153 (7) , 625-632
Abstract
Importance Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) continues to be performed for cervical clearance of obtunded blunt trauma, despite poor evidence regarding its utility after a normal computed tomographic (CT) finding. Objective To evaluate the utility and cost-effectiveness of MRI vs no follow-up after a normal cervical CT finding in patients with obtunded blunt trauma. Design, Setting and Participants This cost-effectiveness analysis evaluated an average patient aged 40 years with blunt trauma from an institutional practice. The analysis used a Markov decision model over a lifetime horizon from a societal perspective with variables from systematic reviews and meta-analyses and reimbursement rates from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, National Spinal Cord Injury Database, and other large published studies. Data were collected from the most recent literature available. Interventions No follow-up vs MRI follow-up after a normal cervical CT finding. Results In the base case of a 40-year-old patient, the cost of MRI follow-up was $14 185 with a health benefit of 24.02 quality-adjusted life-years (QALY); the cost of no follow-up was $1059 with a health benefit of 24.11 QALY, and thus no follow-up was the dominant strategy. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed no follow-up to be the better strategy in all 10 000 iterations. No follow-up was the better strategy when the negative predictive value of the initial CT was relatively high (>98%) or the risk of an injury treated with a cervical collar turning into a permanent neurologic deficit was higher than 25% or when the risk of a missed injury turning into a neurologic deficit was less than 58%. The sensitivity and specificity of MRI were varied simultaneously in a 2-way sensitivity analysis, and no follow-up remained the optimal strategy. Conclusions and Relevance Magnetic resonance imaging had a lower health benefit and a higher cost compared with no follow-up after a normal CT finding in patients with obtunded blunt trauma to the cervical spine, a finding that does not support the use of MRI in this group of patients. The conclusion is robust in sensitivity analyses varying key variables in the model. More literature on these key variables is needed before MRI can be considered to be beneficial in the evaluation of obtunded blunt trauma.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Canadian Cervical Spine Rule Compared With Computed Tomography: A Prospective AnalysisJournal of Trauma: Injury, Infection & Critical Care, 2011
- Diagnostic and prognostic role of MRI in spinal trauma, its comparison and correlation with clinical profile and neurological outcome, according to ASIA impairment scaleJournal of Craniovertebral Junction and Spine, 2011
- Computed Tomography Alone Versus Computed Tomography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Identification of Occult Injuries to the Cervical Spine: A Meta-AnalysisJournal of Trauma: Injury, Infection & Critical Care, 2010
- Risks associated with magnetic resonance imaging and cervical collar in comatose, blunt trauma patients with negative comprehensive cervical spine computed tomography and no apparent spinal deficitCritical Care, 2008
- Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) in the Clearance of the Cervical Spine in Blunt Trauma: A Meta-AnalysisJournal of Trauma: Injury, Infection & Critical Care, 2008
- Is Magnetic Resonance Imaging Essential in Clearing the Cervical Spine in Obtunded Patients With Blunt Trauma?Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection & Critical Care, 2007
- Computed Tomography for Early and Safe Discontinuation of Cervical Spine Immobilization in Obtunded Multiply Injured PatientsJournal of Trauma: Injury, Infection & Critical Care, 2007
- Treatment of venous thromboembolism with vitamin K antagonists: patients’ health state valuations and treatment preferencesThrombosis and Haemostasis, 2004
- Radiographic Assessment of the Cervical Spine in Asymptomatic Trauma PatientsNeurosurgery, 2002
- THE ETIOLOGY OF MISSED CERVICAL SPINE INJURIES1993