Why Community? Reading Difference and Singularity with Community
Authors:
- 1 September 2005
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space
- Vol. 37 (9) , 1589-1611
Abstract
Geographers have increasingly recognised that communities are not homogeneous social formations but contain great diversity and are meaningful in a variety of material, relational and political ways. This has resulted in the apparently contradictory notion of “community with difference”; that community may be performed even while heterogeneity and disagreement are present. But geographers have yet to address satisfactorily the question of why communities continue to be the subject of fascination and study when attempts at definition have proved so problematic. Following on from Young's critique of community, this paper first engages the work of Nancy and Secomb to consider Nancy's conceptualisation of ‘singularity’ as a way to explain the human construction of—and possible need for—notions of community. In short we address the why community? question. Using a rural Australian case study, we demonstrate that meanings of community reflect many differences. This case also illustrates the role of human singularity in the negotiation of these differences, defining the manner in which individual perspectives of community are articulated as well as underpinning people's responses and struggles when ideas of community are challenged.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Work of Literature and the Unworking of Community or Writing in Eltit's LumpericaCR: The New Centennial Review, 2003
- Between Borinquen and the Barrio: Environmental Justice and New York City's Puerto Rican Community, 1969–1972Antipode, 2002
- The Sacred Heart of DissentCR: The New Centennial Review, 2002
- Community, Assimilation, and the UnfamiliarPhilosophy & Rhetoric, 2002
- Contradictions of Community: Questions of Identity for Young British Muslim WomenEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 1999
- Towards a Supply-Chain Community? Insights from Governance Processes in the Food IndustryEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 1999
- Reconceptualising local community: environment, identity and threatArea, 1997
- Community and the "Absolutely Feminine"diacritics, 1996
- Regulation Theory and Rural Research: Theorising Contemporary Rural ChangeEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 1995
- Locality and Community: Coming to Terms with PlaceThe Sociological Review, 1993