Sustainable development in the WTO: from mutual supportiveness to balancing
- 1 July 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in World Trade Review
- Vol. 11 (4) , 621-639
Abstract
The WTO Secretariat describes sustainable development as a central WTO principle. Relevant international law treaties have declared sustainable development's mutual supportiveness with trade liberalization, and also emphasized the need to balance its ‘pillars’: economic development, often equated with trade liberalization, with environmental conservation and social welfare. While ‘mutual supportiveness’ suggests that sustainable development's environmental and social goals are a side effect of trade liberalization, ‘balancing’ involves weighing these different goals, and prompts the difficult question of which are most important, and who is empowered to decide. This paper traces these two broad theoretical conceptions through WTO legal texts, negotiations and dispute settlement, arguing that they have important pragmatic implications. In particular, to create mutual supportiveness WTO Director-General, Pascal Lamy, has stated the need for adequate domestic policies, suggesting that the WTO should support these. Yet, if they have negative trade impacts, pure ‘sustainable development’ policies may be difficult to balance against the WTO obligation to liberalize trade.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Treaty Interpretation by the WTO Appellate Body2009
- Trade and the Environment2009
- Treaty Interpretation and the WTO Appellate Body Report in US – Gambling: A CritiqueJournal of International Economic Law, 2006
- The WTO Case Law of 20022005
- Dispute Settlement in the World Trade Organization2004
- The Role of “Sustainability Labelling” in the International Law of Sustainable Development2004
- The World Trade Organization's legitimacy crisisWorld Trade Review, 2002
- Proportionality in WTO LawJournal of International Economic Law, 2001
- Power, rules and principles - which orientation for WTO/GATT law?Journal of International Economic Law, 2001
- Trade and... Problems, Cost-Benefit Analysis and SubsidiarityEuropean Journal of International Law, 1998