The Comparative Accuracy of Two Hydrologic Models in Simulating Warm‐Season Runoff for Two Small, Hillslope Catchments
- 21 October 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Jawra Journal of the American Water Resources Association
- Vol. 50 (2) , 434-447
Abstract
This article assesses the performance of two hydrologic models in simulating warm‐season runoff for two upland, low‐yield micro‐catchments near Coshocton, Ohio. The two models, namely the Storm Water Management Model (SWMM) and the Gridded Surface‐Subsurface Hydrologic Analysis (GSSHA), were implemented with contrasting levels of complexity, with the former representing the catchments as lumped spatial units and computing evaporation only from standing water, and the latter incorporating fine‐scale variation in topography and soil properties and computing evapotranspiration from soil based on weather data. Our investigation began with uncalibrated model runs for 1990‐2003 except for 1994 using a priori parameter values. Then a set of calibration experiments were performed wherein the sensitivity of model performance to the length of calibration records was examined. Our results pointed to large errors associated with simulations from both models: even the calibrated models were unable to reproduce the seasonal and between‐catchment contrasts in runoff response. Using a priori parameter values, SWMM attained better results than GSSHA. However, with simple calibration, GSSHA outperformed SWMM in several respects. It was also found that extending the record of calibration rendered relatively minor changes to model performance. The practical and scientific implications of the findings are discussed.Keywords
Funding Information
- USEPA
- Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hillslope threshold response to rainfall: (1) A field based forensic approachJournal of Hydrology, 2010
- Fast and efficient optimization of hydrologic model parameters using a priori estimates and stepwise line searchJournal of Hydrology, 2008
- Using SSURGO data to improve Sacramento Model a priori parameter estimatesJournal of Hydrology, 2006
- Effects of land-use changes on the hydrologic response of reclamation systemsPhysics and Chemistry of the Earth, Parts A/B/C, 2005
- Modelling of macropore flow and transport processes at catchment scaleJournal of Hydrology, 2004
- Overall distributed model intercomparison project resultsJournal of Hydrology, 2004
- Calibration of a semi-distributed hydrologic model for streamflow estimation along a river systemJournal of Hydrology, 2004
- Prediction of runoff and soil moistures at the watershed scale: Effects of model complexity and parameter assignmentWater Resources Research, 2003
- Investigating the relationship between a soils classification and the spatial parameters of a conceptual catchment-scale hydrological modelJournal of Hydrology, 2001
- Modelling of runoff generation and soil moisture dynamics for hillslopes and micro-catchmentsJournal of Hydrology, 1997