Competition Versus Cooperation: Implications for Music Teachers following Students Feedback from Participation in a Large-scale Cooperative Music Festival
Authors:
- Edith Cowan UniversityEUEdith Cowan University
Open Access
- 1 May 2018
- journal article
- Published by Edith Cowan University in Australian Journal of Teacher Education
- Vol. 43 (5) , 78-94
Abstract
Competition is reported in the general education literature as having a largely detrimental impact upon student engagement and long-term motivation, yet competition has long been an accepted part of the music education ensemble landscape. Adjudicated ensemble competitions and competition-festivals are commonplace in most Australian states, as opposed to large-scale cooperative events. Arguments advanced in support of competitive events revolve primarily around perceived extra-musical benefits framed from the director / conductor perspective. The student voice is rarely considered in assessments of the impact of participation. This study presents student feedback following participation in an alternative large-scale cooperative music ensemble festival. Students were surveyed immediately after the event, and key findings revealed enhanced enjoyment and motivation to continue and improve across all year levels and playing groups following the cooperative festival. These findings indicate the need for music educators to rethink the purpose of large-scale music ensemble events, understand the potential of cooperative events in promoting long-term musical engagement, and highlight the importance and value of acknowledging the student voice.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sight over sound in the judgment of music performanceProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2013
- Effect of Verbal Praise on Achievement Goal Orientation, Motivation, and Performance AttributionJournal of Music Teacher Education, 2012
- Lessons for teachers: What lower secondary school students tell us about learning a musical instrumentInternational Journal of Music Education, 2012
- Advanced youth music ensembles: Experiences of, and reasons for, participationInternational Journal of Music Education, 2012
- The Effects of Competition on Improvisers’ Motivation, Stress, and Creative PerformanceCreativity Research Journal, 2011
- Competition: Was Kohn Right?Phi Delta Kappan, 2010
- Transformative approaches to student voice: theoretical underpinnings, recalcitrant realitiesBritish Educational Research Journal, 2004
- Efficiency and Inefficiency in the Ranking in Competitions: the Case of the Queen Elisabeth Music ContestJournal of Cultural Economics, 2001
- Competitive and Non-Competitive Goal Structures: An Analysis of Motivation and Achievement among Elementary Band StudentsPsychology of Music, 1991
- Motivational processes affecting learning.American Psychologist, 1986