In this chapter, numerous student stories illuminate the important role of teaching strategies in student engagement. Students shared examples of how their professors attended to their mental health and well-being and used teaching methods that they perceived to be inclusive and affirming. Student stories illustrate their appreciation for professors prioritizing collaborative learning opportunities in online courses. Students found it engaging to connect with peers in both synchronous and asynchronous learning environments and shared examples of how their professors structured and supported these collaborative learning opportunities. Examples of how professors incorporated the use of technology tools to engage students are also shared. Finally, students noted they were engaged when their professors kept it fresh by using varied and innovative teaching approaches.