Juror motivations: applying procedural justice theory to juror decision making
- 1 December 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Psychology, Crime & Law
- Vol. 27 (6) , 606-629
Abstract
Jurors sometimes consider inadmissible evidence in their verdicts, despite judicial instructions to disregard that evidence. Procedural justice research suggests this is because jurors are motivated to prioritise just outcomes over due process; thus, jurors’ non-compliance towards judicial instructions to disregard inadmissible evidence may be the product of a discrepancy between legal and lay peoples’ understanding of the juror’s role. In this mixed-method design, we examined 294 university students’ a priori perceptions about the role and responsibility of jurors, and empirically tested how randomly assigning participants to the role of a juror (versus a judge’s associate/assistant, who helps the judge to ensure a trial is conducted according to proper procedure) influenced their verdict decisions, prioritisation of outcome versus procedural considerations, motivation to protect the community, and perceived obligation to ensure correct procedures. Overall, the results demonstrated ambivalence in lay people’s perceptions of the juror role, with many participants perceiving jurors to be responsible for protecting society; however, we did not find support for our predictions that participants assigned the role of a juror (versus judge’s associate) would more strongly prioritise outcomes over procedures. Methodological issues, recommendations for future research, and implications are also discussed.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Impact on Juror Verdicts of Judicial Instruction to Disregard Inadmissible Evidence: A Meta-Analysis.Law and Human Behavior, 2006
- Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2006
- The influence of prior record evidence on juror decision making.Law and Human Behavior, 1995
- Expert evidence and hearsay: The influence of "secondhand" information on jurors' decisions.Law and Human Behavior, 1995
- You Can′t Always Forget What You Want: Directed Forgetting of Related WordsJournal of Memory and Language, 1994
- When Instructions to Forget Become Instructions to RememberPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1994
- Trial complexity: A field investigation of its meaning and its effects.Law and Human Behavior, 1994
- Instructions to disregard potentially useful information: The effects of pragmatics on evaluative judgments and recallJournal of Memory and Language, 1990
- The moderator–mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1986
- On the inefficacy of limiting instructions: When jurors use prior conviction evidence to decide on guilt.Law and Human Behavior, 1985