Distill-and-Compare: Auditing Black-Box Models Using Transparent Model Distillation

Authors:
  • STSarah Tan
    Sarah Tan
  • RCRich Caruana
    Rich Caruana
  • GHGiles Hooker
    Giles Hooker
  • YLYin Lou
    Yin Lou
Preprint
Publisher website
Google Scholar
Abstract
Black-box risk scoring models permeate our lives, yet are typically proprietary or opaque. We propose Distill-and-Compare, a model distillation and comparison approach to audit such models. To gain insight into black-box models, we treat them as teachers, training transparent student models to mimic the risk scores assigned by black-box models. We compare the student model trained with distillation to a second un-distilled transparent model trained on ground-truth outcomes, and use differences between the two models to gain insight into the black-box model. Our approach can be applied in a realistic setting, without probing the black-box model API. We demonstrate the approach on four public data sets: COMPAS, Stop-and-Frisk, Chicago Police, and Lending Club. We also propose a statistical test to determine if a data set is missing key features used to train the black-box model. Our test finds that the ProPublica data is likely missing key feature(s) used in COMPAS.

This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit: