Psychiatric Risk Governance Across Jurisdictions: A Comparative Analysis of Involuntary Treatment, Community Treatment Orders, and Forensic Mental Health Services
Authors:
- Matteo LippiMLMatteo Lippi
- Laura Leondina CampanozziLaura Leondina Campanozzi
- Giuseppe D’andreaGDGiuseppe D’andrea
- Donato MorenaDMDonato Morena
- Francesca OrsiniFOFrancesca Orsini
- Felice Marco DamatoFDFelice Marco Damato
- Giuseppe FanelliGFGiuseppe Fanelli
- Yasin Hasan BalciogluYBYasin Hasan Balcioglu
- Howard RylandHRHoward Ryland
- Thomas FovetTFThomas Fovet
- Birgit VöllmBVBirgit Völlm
- Javier Vicente-AlbaJVJavier Vicente-Alba
Open Access
- 20 September 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by MDPI AG in Healthcare
- Vol. 13 (18) , 2363
Abstract
Background: This article presents an international comparative review of involuntary psychiatric care, Community Treatment Orders (CTOs), and forensic mental health services, with operational implications for Italy. Italy has a community-based model inspired by the “Basaglia Law” (Law No. 180/1978), emphasizing deinstitutionalization and continuity of care. Nevertheless, risk governance gaps persist for high-complexity patients, imposing a disproportionate legal and clinical burden on mental health professionals. This group includes individuals who refuse treatment despite meeting criteria for compulsory admission, patients at elevated risk with substantial management complexity, and offenders with a current or suspected psychiatric disorder. Methods: We conducted a comparative legal and policy review across seven jurisdictions (Italy, England and Wales (UK), France, Germany, Spain, the United States, and Canada) to map frameworks for involuntary treatment, forensic services, CTOs (or equivalents), and community-based risk management. We also extracted procedural safeguards, duration and renewal limits, and interfaces with forensic services. Results: CTOs are available in five of the seven jurisdictions (England and Wales, France, Spain, the United States, and Canada) but are absent in Italy and Germany. We propose a three-pillar framework: (1) enforceable outpatient measures, including CTOs; (2) Forensic Psychiatry Units within Local Health Authorities; and (3) oversight boards with judicial, clinical, and social representatives. These components aim to redistribute responsibility, ensure continuity of care, and provide proportional oversight within a least restrictive, graduated system. Conclusions: When narrowly targeted, time limited, and paired with robust safeguards and service-quality standards, CTOs can support adherence and continuity for patients who repeatedly disengage from care. For Italy, integrating this instrument within the three-pillar framework and under independent oversight could strengthen patient rights and public safety, reduce revolving-door admissions, and improve outcomes.Keywords
This publication has 112 references indexed in Scilit:
- Well-Being Parameters and Intention to Leave Current Institution Among Academic PhysiciansJAMA Network Open, 2023
- Hospital treatment of persons found not guilty by reason of insanityBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2020
- The question of sanity restoration in jailBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2020
- Standards für die Behandlung im Maßregelvollzug nach §§ 63 und 64 StGBDer Nervenarzt, 2017
- Compulsory community and involuntary outpatient treatment for people with severe mental disordersCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2017
- Compulsion and “coercion” in mental health careWorld Psychiatry, 2015
- Dynamic and Static Factors Associated with Discharge Dispositions: The National Trajectory Project of Individuals Found Not Criminally Responsible on Account of Mental Disorder (NCRMD) in CanadaBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2014
- Timeliness of second opinion appointed doctors' assessments of treatment plans for patients detained in medium security hospitals in London, UKCriminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 2013
- Preventive Detention in Germany: An Overview and Empirical Data from Two Federal StatesBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2013
- Compulsory admission of mentally ill patients in European Union Member StatesSocial Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 2004