The Ethics of Innovation: Ethical Decision-Making and Review for Field Studies and Projects Targeting Dogs and Cats
Open Access
Abstract
To date, independent ethical oversight of many companion animal welfare initiatives has been limited and, in some instances, inadequate. Beyond a blurred line between “innovation” and “research,” the nature of the work conducted in animal welfare projects is often poorly aligned with established institutional ethical review structures, which are designed for research involving humans or research involving animals and are also focused on industry and academic institutions. This commentary details the struggle of one United States-based nonprofit organization to find ethical guidelines and support for conducting non-traditional field-based animal welfare studies, and subsequent experience establishing an Ethical Review Board to evaluate organizational initiatives. The commentary discusses member selection, materials and processes, and lessons and learnings from the creation and use of an Ethical Review Board. Sharing content of the ethical review process, as well as challenges and learnings from it, is intended to support other organizations and individuals seeking to ensure that innovation for animal welfare consistently meets high ethical standards.Keywords
Funding Information
- Private funder (Margaret R. Slater) (Not applicable)
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Recommendations for Ethical Review of Veterinary Clinical TrialsFrontiers in Veterinary Science, 2021
- Patchless administration of canine influenza vaccine on dog’s ear using insertion-responsive microneedles (IRMN) without removal of hair and its in vivo efficacy evaluationEuropean Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics, 2020
- Advancing Ethical Principles for Non-Invasive, Respectful Research with Nonhuman Animal ParticipantsSociety & Animals, 2020
- Hybrid model intermediate between a laboratory and field study: A humane paradigm shift in feline researchJournal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 2018
- Effectiveness of GonaCon as an immunocontraceptive in colony-housed catsJournal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 2018
- Exploring the Gaps in Practical Ethical Guidance for Animal Welfare Considerations of Field Interventions and Innovations Targeting Dogs and CatsAnimals, 2018
- Rabies vaccination in dogs using a dissolving microneedle patchJournal of Controlled Release, 2016
- Current concepts of Harm–Benefit Analysis of Animal Experiments – Report from the AALAS–FELASA Working Group on Harm–Benefit Analysis – Part 1Laboratory Animals, 2016
- The Routledge Handbook of Political Ecology2015