Characteristics, Predictors and Reasons for Regulatory Body Disciplinary Action in Health Care: A Scoping Review
Authors:
- Ai-Leng Foong-ReichertAFAi-Leng Foong-Reichert
- Ariane FungAFAriane Fung
- Caitlin A. CarterCCCaitlin A. Carter
- Kelly A. GrindrodKGKelly A. Grindrod
- Sherilyn K.D. HouleSHSherilyn K.D. Houle
Open Access
- 1 December 2021
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Federation of State Medical Boards in Journal of Medical Regulation
- Vol. 107 (4) , 17-31
Abstract
What research has been done to characterize the outcomes of disciplinary action or fitness-to-practice cases for regulated health professionals?To answer this research question, relevant publications were identified in PubMed, Ovid EMBASE, CINAHL via EBSCOhost, and Scopus. Included papers focused on reviews of regulatory body disciplinary action for regulated health professionals.Of 108 papers that were included, 84 studied reasons for discipline, 68 studied penalties applied, and 89 studied characteristics/predictors of discipline. Most were observational studies that used administrative data such as regulatory body discipline cases. Studies were published between 1990–2020, with two-thirds published from 2010–2020. Most research has focused on physicians (64%), nurses (10%), multiple health professionals (8.3%), dentists (6.5%) and pharmacists (5.5%). Most research has originated from the United States (53%), United Kingdom (16%), Australia (9.2%), and Canada (6.5%). Characteristics that were reviewed included: gender, age, years in practice, practice specialty, license type/profession, previous disciplinary action, board certification, and performance on licensing examinations.As most research has focused on physicians and has originated from the United States, more research on other professions and jurisdictions is needed. Lack of standardization in disciplinary processes and definitions used to categorize reasons for discipline is a barrier to comparison across jurisdictions and professions. Future research on characteristics and predictors should be used to improve equity, support practitioners, and decrease disciplinary action.Keywords
This publication has 91 references indexed in Scilit:
- Characteristics of complaints resulting in disciplinary actions against Danish GPsScandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care, 2013
- The Characteristics of Psychiatrists Disciplined by Professional Colleges in CanadaPLOS ONE, 2012
- Pharmacists subjected to disciplinary action: characteristics and risk factorsInternational Journal of Pharmacy Practice, 2011
- Licensed Nurses Disciplined in Oregon Between September 1996 and June 2008Western Journal of Nursing Research, 2010
- Discipline of NursesJONA's Healthcare Law, Ethics, and Regulation, 2008
- Disciplinary careers of drug-impaired physiciansSocial Science & Medicine, 2007
- A follow-up evaluation of sexual misconduct complaints: The Oregon Board of Medical Examiners, 1998 through 2002American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2004
- A Threat to Competent and Safe Nursing PracticeJONA's Healthcare Law, Ethics, and Regulation, 1999
- Professional misconductOphthalmic and Physiological Optics, 1995
- The Enforcement of Regulations Restricting Expanded Duties by Dental Auxiliaries: an Analysis of the Recent Disciplinary Actions of the Texas State Board of Dental ExaminersJournal of Public Health Dentistry, 1991