Resetting the Evaluation Indicators for School Garden Education Service
Open Access
- 30 June 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Korean Society for People, Plants, and Environment in Journal of People, Plants, and Environment
- Vol. 24 (3) , 245-256
Abstract
Background and objective The vitalization of urban agriculture has increased various forms of experience-based education using school gardens, which raised the importance of school gardens in terms of value as well as the need to develop an implementation system for education-based agricultural experience service using school gardens. Thus, we reset the evaluation indicators from the previous study to establish objective evaluation indicators that enable quantitative comparison of school garden education services. Methods Analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and direct question (DQ) surveys were conducted on 20 experts from October 12 to 19, 2020 after establishing the purpose and subjects of evaluation, and then the weights were calculated using the Expert Choice 2010 program. Results First, we analyzed the problems of the previous indicators by categorizing the performance indicators and comparing and verifying them with six requirements of valuation. Then, we added ‘welfare values’ and established sub-indicators accordingly. The importance of value indicator in AHP was in the order of education values (0.544), health values (0.182), welfare values (0.164), environmental values (0.062), and economic values (0.049). The importance of environmental and economic values was relatively low, less than 0.1. The importance of sub-indicators was highest in cultivating character (0.144), followed by enhancing ecological sensitivity (0.141) > promoting mental health (0.134) > cultivating agricultural literacy (0.120) > improving social skills (0.104). And mitigating climate change in environmental values was lowest (0.009). Increase in income was the lowest (0.036). This can be regarded as the expression of change to increase the educational effect based on collective life and the connotative meaning of ‘school’. In the case of DQ, the AHP weight and order were the same, but the environmental and economic values were relatively low, and the result was different from AHP weight. For sub-indicators, the importance in DQ was highest in promoting mental health (0.136), followed by promoting physical health (0.085), ]cultivating character (0.082), social integration (0.072), and enhancing ecological sensitivity (0.071). After reviewing related experts, we came up with 5 evaluation indicators and 16 sub-indicators for school garden education service, which are objective evaluation indicators that enable quantitative comparison. Conclusion In the future, we will validate the socioeconomic values of school garden education services and contribute to revitalizing school gardens by establishing policy alternatives for effective operation and management of school gardens.Keywords
Funding Information
- Rural Development Administration (PJ01364403)
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Derivation of Indicators for Value Assessment of School GardensJournal of People, Plants, and Environment, 2020
- Set up and Running Status of School Gardening at Elementary Schools: Focus on Jeollabuk-doThe Korean Journal of Community Living Science, 2017
- Adoption of Emotional Intelligence Education in Elementary Horticulture Education and Survey of It s Recognition to Teachers2017
- Effects of Container Vegetable Gardening on the Improvement of Scientific Interest, Social Ability, and Academic Achievement for Elementary StudentsJournal of Korean Society for People Plants and Environment, 2012
- Impact of the Use of Produce Grown in an Elementary School Garden on Consumption of Vegetables at School LunchJournal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition, 2012
- Growing Minds: The Effect of a School Gardening Program on the Science Achievement of Elementary StudentsHortTechnology, 2005
- School-based gardens can teach kids healthier eating habitsCalifornia Agriculture, 2000