Do economically meaningful quote differences convey private information?
Authors:
- Andy FodorAFAndy Fodor
- Cagri Berk OnukCOCagri Berk Onuk
- Corey ShankCSCorey Shank
Preprint
- 28 February 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
We provide a direct test of whether economically meaningful quote differences necessarily convey private information. Using college football and NFL betting markets, we exploit mechanically generated payoff discontinuities created by discrete scoring rules that concentrate probability mass at “key numbers” such as three and seven. Half-point spread changes that cross these thresholds produce first-order shifts in expected value while holding fundamentals constant, delivering clean identification unavailable in traditional financial markets. Using bettor-level contract data, we document large and discontinuous reallocations of wagering demand when spreads cross key numbers. Yet these economically large quote differences do not systematically predict realized returns or bookmaker profitability. Despite inducing substantial quantity responses, threshold crossings are informationally empty. Our findings indicate that discrete quote placement primarily reflects predictable demand elasticity rather than informational shading. More broadly, the results caution against interpreting threshold crossings, price clustering, or support and resistance phenomena as evidence of private information and provide a benchmark for understanding discrete pricing in market microstructure.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Is market fragmentation harming market quality?Journal of Financial Economics, 2011
- How Much Does Expertise Reduce Behavioral Biases? The Case of Anchoring Effects in Stock Return EstimatesFinancial Management, 2008
- Market structure, fragmentation, and market qualityJournal of Financial Markets, 2006
- The 52‐Week High and Momentum InvestingThe Journal of Finance, 2004
- Why are Gambling Markets Organised so Differently from Financial Markets?The Economic Journal, 2004
- The degree of price resolution and equity trading costsJournal of Financial Economics, 1997
- Stock Price Clustering and DiscretenessThe Review of Financial Studies, 1991
- Estimating the components of the bid/ask spreadJournal of Financial Economics, 1988
- Bid, ask and transaction prices in a specialist market with heterogeneously informed tradersJournal of Financial Economics, 1985
- Optimal dealer pricing under transactions and return uncertaintyJournal of Financial Economics, 1981