179 To Scan or Not to Scan

Authors:
  • PSPhilippe Schucht
    Philippe Schucht
  • UFUrs Fischer
    Urs Fischer
  • CFChristian Fung
    Christian Fung
  • CBCorrado Bernasconi
    Corrado Bernasconi
  • JFJens Fichtner
    Jens Fichtner
  • SVSonja Vulcu
    Sonja Vulcu
  • ANAndreas Nowacki
    Andreas Nowacki
  • SWStefan Wanderer
    Stefan Wanderer
  • CEChristian Eisenring
    Christian Eisenring
  • AJAnna-Katharina Jetzer
    Anna-Katharina Jetzer
  • NSNicole Soell
    Nicole Soell

Abstract
Chronic subdural hematoma has a high recurrence rate after surgery and postoperative scans often show substantial residuals, eventually leading to a higher rate of reoperation. However, the benefit of postsurgical imaging for patient outcome remains unknown. We randomly assigned 368 patients with newly diagnosed chronic subdural hematoma within 48 h after surgery to either a combined radiological and clinical follow-up (CT arm) or a clinical follow-up with scans only in case of neurological deterioration (no-CT arm). The primary outcome was the modified Rankin scale (mRS) score at 90 d; this categorical scale measures functional outcome, with scores ranging from 0 (no symptoms) to 6 (death). A follow-up protocol with CT imaging did not improve the primary outcome; there was no significant between-arm difference for mRS as a categorical variable (P = .79) or as numerical variable (P = .37). The proportion of patients who survived without severe disability (mRS 0-3) was 89% in the CT arm and 93% in the no-CT arm (odds ratio 1.4, 95% confidence interval 3.72-0.82, P = .15). Death occurred in 12 patients in the CT arm and in 8 patients in the no-CT arm (P = .5). Re-operation for recurrent hematomas was performed in 59 patients in the CT arm and in 39 patients in the no-CT arm (P = .055). Complications were seen in 26 patients in the CT arm and in 19 patients in the no-CT arm (P = .34). Routinely scheduled CT scans after neurosurgical evacuation of chronic subdural hematoma have no benefit on outcome.