The confidence-accuracy relationship in eyewitness identification: Effects of lineup instructions, foil similarity, and target-absent base rates.
Authors:
- Neil BrewerNBNeil Brewer
- Gary L. WellsGWGary L. Wells
- 1 January 2006
- journal article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
- Vol. 12 (1) , 11-30
Abstract
Discriminating accurate from mistaken eyewitness identifications is a major issue facing criminal justice systems. This study examined whether eyewitness confidence assists such decisions under a variety of conditions using a confidence-accuracy (CA) calibration approach. Participants (N = 1,200) viewed a simulated crime and attempted 2 separate identifications from 8-person target-present or target-absent lineups. Confidence and accuracy were calibrated for choosers (but not nonchoosers) for both targets under all conditions. Lower overconfidence was associated with higher diagnosticity, lower target-absent base rates, and shorter identification latencies. Although researchers agree that courtroom expressions of confidence are uninformative, our findings indicate that confidence assessments obtained immediately after a positive identification can provide a useful guide for investigators about the likely accuracy of an identification.Keywords
Funding Information
- Australian Research Council (DP0556876; DP0343548)
This publication has 71 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Re-examination of the Effects of Biased Lineup Instructions in Eyewitness Identification.Law and Human Behavior, 2005
- What we really know about our abilities and our knowledgePersonality and Individual Differences, 2002
- Eyewitness identification: Information gain from incriminating and exonerating behaviors.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2002
- Perceptions of witness behaviour‐accuracy relationships held by police, lawyers and mock‐jurorsPsychiatry, Psychology and Law, 1999
- "Good, you identified the suspect": Feedback to eyewitnesses distorts their reports of the witnessing experience.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1998
- Social influence in eyewitness recall: A meta-analytic review of lineup instruction effects.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- Mock-juror belief of accurate and inaccurate eyewitnesses: A replication and extension.Law and Human Behavior, 1989
- Juror decision making in eyewitness identification cases.Law and Human Behavior, 1988
- The reliability of eyewitness identification: The role of system and estimator variables.Law and Human Behavior, 1987
- Do jurors share a common understanding concerning eyewitness behavior?Law and Human Behavior, 1982