AI Review Bots vs. Humans in Handling Negative Reviews: Who Builds More Trust?
Open Access
- 22 March 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research
- Vol. 21 (3) , 94
Abstract
As artificial intelligence (AI) increasingly engages in managing consumer interactions on e-commerce platforms, an important question arises: how do public AI-generated replies to negative reviews compare with human replies in fostering consumer trust? This study investigates consumer trust in reply source (AI review bots vs. human agents) across three reply strategies, namely, default, thinking, and feeling, in a public review context. AI review bots are defined as automated systems that publicly respond to consumer reviews. Using a controlled laboratory experiment, we find that when using the default strategy, human replies elicit greater trust than AI replies, mediated by higher perceived authenticity and persuasiveness. Conversely, when using the thinking strategy, AI replies outperform human replies in building consumer trust, as they are perceived as more authentic and persuasive. In the feeling strategy, there is a convergence between AI and human replies. These findings demonstrate that the effectiveness of AI versus human replies depends on the strategy adopted. Theoretically, this study extends research on human–AI interaction by introducing a three-strategy framework to systematically compare AI and human communicators in public review contexts. Practically, the results guide e-commerce sellers and platforms on when and how to deploy AI review bots to effectively manage consumer trust in response to negative reviews.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (72572088)
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (32400939)
This publication has 79 references indexed in Scilit:
- A tale of two platforms: A comparative analysis of language use in consumer complaints on Reddit and Spotify CommunityJournal of Consumer Behaviour, 2024
- Exploring the effect of humor in robot failureAnnals of Tourism Research, 2022
- AI-powered chatbot communication with customers: Dialogic interactions, satisfaction, engagement, and customer behaviorComputers in Human Behavior, 2022
- The effects of parasocial interaction, authenticity, and self‐congruity on the formation of consumer trust in online travel agenciesInternational Journal of Tourism Research, 2022
- Artificial intelligence service recovery: The role of empathic response in hospitality customers’ continuous usage intentionComputers in Human Behavior, 2022
- Service failure recovery on customer recovery satisfaction for airline industry: The moderator of brand authenticity and perceived authenticityManagerial and Decision Economics, 2021
- Keeping It Real: How Perceived Brand Authenticity Affects Product PerceptionsJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2019
- Tell it like it is: The effects of differing responses to negative online reviewsPsychology & Marketing, 2018
- How to deal with online consumer comments during a crisis? The impact of personalized organizational responses on organizational reputationComputers in Human Behavior, 2017
- The effects of response strategies and severity of failure on consumer attribution with regard to negative word-of-mouthDecision Support Systems, 2015