Abstract
Biogeographic patterns of marine organisms can be related to historical or ecological factors. In either case, an organism's dispersal capabilities may have an impact on rates of speciation, extinction, and species longevity. One way to assess these factors is to compare patterns and trends in developmental modes among closely related taxa across different environments. The Caribbean and the eastern Pacific differ greatly in primary productivity and seasonality. The latter is more seasonal and productive, and these differences have existed for several million years. Likewise, reproductive propagules (eggs, larvae) of echinoderms, corals, and bryozoans are smaller or mostly planktonic in the eastern Pacific when compared with the Caribbean. This is probably due to the greater seasonality and higher productivity of the eastern Pacific, as opposed to the more stable, less productive Caribbean. This study used protoconch morphology to infer developmental patterns for 84 recent species of columbellid gastropods of the Strombina group, Conus, Oliva, and Olivella. Planktotrophy predominates within the eastern Pacific, whereas Caribbean species show mostly non-planktotrophic development. Thus mollusks exhibit the same differences between these two oceans as the other phyla. Most studies of evolutionary trends in modes of development have been done for north Atlantic and Mediterranean species. There, non-planktotrophic development increases with latitude and bathymetry. However, our data from the Eastern Pacific indicates that the widely reported tendency to evolve from planktotrophic to direct development may reflect changing environmental conditions in the Atlantic rather than an inevitable evolutionary trend. These results agree with a few studies for the south Atlantic and Antarctic regions that indicate that latitudinal and bathymetric constraints on developmental modes are probably much more complex than initially assumed. Moreover, the effects imposed by phylogeny on life histories can either direct or constrain the observed shifts in developmental types.

This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit: