American Indian identity theft (self-indigenization, pretendianism) is usually treated as oneperson’s deception. I argue that it is something larger. This article presents InternalDispossession Theory (IDT), a sovereignty-grounded theory of the harms of American Indianidentity theft. Its premise is that identity theft is the latest form of colonial dispossession: asNative land and resources were taken, so too is the authority of tribal nations to say who belongs,relocated from the nation onto individuals, institutions, and markets. That relocation producesrelational, structural, and epistemic harms that culminate in internal dispossession: the erosion ofa tribal nation’s capacity to define itself, lived also by the individual Native person whose place acounterfeit takes. Stated as nine propositions and grounded in a sovereign autoethnography of adocumented case, IDT names a contemporary colonial mechanism. Its remedy is not institutionalgatekeeping but tribal self-determination.