Consensus and contention regarding redundant publications in clinical research: cross-sectional survey of editors and authors
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 April 2003
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 29 (2) , 109-114
Abstract
Objectives:To examine the perspectives of journal editors and authors on overlapping and redundant publications in clinical research.Design:Pretested cross-sectional survey, containing both forced choice and open ended questions, administered by mail to the senior editors (N=99) and one randomly selected author (N=99) from all journals in theAbridged Index Medicus(1996) that published clinical research.Main measurements:The views of editors and authors about the extent of redundant publications, why they occur, how to prevent and respond to cases, and when the publication of overlapping manuscripts is justified.Results:Seventy two per cent (N=71) of editors and 65% (N=64) of authors completed the survey. There was consensus between both groups that redundant publications occur because authors feel the pressure to publish and journals do not do enough to publicise, criticise, and punish cases, and that the publication of most types of overlapping articles is unacceptable. Sixty seven per cent of authors but only 31% of editors felt, however, that it was justified to publish an overlapping article in a non-peer reviewed symposium supplement, and 68% of editors but 39% of authors supported imposing restrictions on guilty authors’ future submissions. In written comments, 15% to 30% of both groups emphasised that it was justified to publish overlapping articles when there were different or non-English-speaking audiences, new data, strengthened methods, or disputed findings.Conclusions:Editors, authors, and other academic leaders should together develop explicit guidelines that clarify points of contention and ambiguity regarding overlapping manuscripts.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Notice of duplicate publicationThorax, 2002
- Publication ethics and the research assessment exercise: reflections on the troubled question of authorshipJournal of Medical Ethics, 2000
- Addiction journals: amazing happenings, landmark meeting, historic consensus, evolving processAddiction, 1997
- Longitude and longevityScience, 1997
- Misrepresentation of Research Publications Among Emergency Medicine Residency ApplicantsGurudevan & MowerAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 1996
- Duplicate publication in the nursing literatureImage: the Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 1995
- Redundant Publication: Déjà Vu All Over AgainHepatology, 1992
- Is duplicate publishing on the increase?BMJ, 1992
- Dual Publication and Manipulation of the Editorial ProcessInternational Journal of Dermatology, 1990
- Redundant PublicationNew England Journal of Medicine, 1989