UK Women’s Views of the Concepts of Personalised Breast Cancer Risk Assessment and Risk-Stratified Breast Screening: A Qualitative Interview Study
Open Access
Abstract
Any introduction of risk-stratification within the NHS Breast Screening Programme needs to be considered acceptable by women. We conducted interviews to explore women’s attitudes to personalised risk assessment and risk-stratified breast screening. Twenty-five UK women were purposively sampled by screening experience and socioeconomic background. Interview transcripts were qualitatively analysed using Framework Analysis. Women expressed positive intentions for personal risk assessment and willingness to receive risk feedback to provide reassurance and certainty. Women responded to risk-stratified screening scenarios in three ways: ‘Overall acceptors’ considered both high- and low-risk options acceptable as a reasonable allocation of resources to clinical need, yet acceptability was subject to specified conditions including accuracy of risk estimates and availability of support throughout the screening pathway. Others who thought ‘more is better’ only supported high-risk scenarios where increased screening was proposed. ‘Screening sceptics’ found low-risk scenarios more aligned to their screening values than high-risk screening options. Consideration of screening recommendations for other risk groups had more influence on women’s responses than screening-related harms. These findings demonstrate high, but not universal, acceptability. Support and guidance, tailored to screening values and preferences, may be required by women at all levels of risk.Keywords
Funding Information
- Breakthrough Breast Cancer (2018NovPhD1265)
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Risk determination and prevention of breast cancerBreast Cancer Research, 2014
- Cost-Effectiveness and Harm-Benefit Analyses of Risk-Based Screening Strategies for Breast CancerPLOS ONE, 2014
- Stratified Cancer Screening: The Practicalities of ImplementationPublic Health Genomics, 2013
- Cancer Screening Campaigns — Getting Past Uninformative PersuasionNew England Journal of Medicine, 2012
- The genomic and transcriptomic architecture of 2,000 breast tumours reveals novel subgroupsNature, 2012
- Breast cancer risk prediction and individualised screening based on common genetic variation and breast density measurementBreast Cancer Research, 2012
- ‘A Low Risk Is Still a Risk’: Exploring Women’s Attitudes towards Genetic Testing for Breast Cancer Susceptibility in Order to Target Disease PreventionPublic Health Genomics, 2010
- Mammographic Breast Density as a General Marker of Breast Cancer RiskCancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention, 2007
- Anomalies: The Endowment Effect, Loss Aversion, and Status Quo BiasJournal of Economic Perspectives, 1991
- Psychological side effects of breast cancer screening.Health Psychology, 1991