Accuracy and Precision of Four Value-Added Blood Glucose Meters: the Abbott Optium, the DDI Prodigy, the HDI True Track, and the HypoGuard Assure Pro
Authors:
- 1 September 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics
- Vol. 11 (9) , 587-592
Abstract
Purpose: This study compared the accuracy and precision of four value-added glucose meters. Methods: Finger stick glucose measurements in diabetes patients were performed using the Abbott Diabetes Care (Alameda, CA) Optium™, Diagnostic Devices, Inc. (Miami, FL) DDI Prodigy®, Home Diagnostics, Inc. (Fort Lauderdale, FL) HDI True Track Smart System®, and Arkray, USA (Minneapolis, MN) HypoGuard Assure® Pro. Finger glucose measurements were compared with laboratory reference results. Accuracy was assessed by a Clarke error grid analysis (EGA), a Parkes EGA, and within 5%, 10%, 15%, and 20% of the laboratory value criteria (χ2 analysis). Meter precision was determined by calculating absolute mean differences in glucose values between duplicate samples (Kruskal-Wallis test). Results: Finger sticks were obtained from 125 diabetes patients, of which 90.4% were Caucasian, 51.2% were female, 83.2% had type 2 diabetes, and average age of 59 years (SD 14 years). Mean venipuncture blood glucose was 151 mg/dL (SD ±65 mg/dL; range, 58–474 mg/dL). Clinical accuracy by Clarke EGA was demonstrated in 94% of Optium, 82% of Prodigy, 61% of True Track, and 77% of the Assure Pro samples (P < 0.05 for Optium and True Track compared to all others). By Parkes EGA, the True Track was significantly less accurate than the other meters. Within 5% accuracy was achieved in 34%, 24%, 29%, and 13%, respectively (P < 0.05 for Optium, Prodigy, and Assure Pro compared to True Track). Within 10% accuracy was significantly greater for the Optium, Prodigy, and Assure Pro compared to True Track. Significantly more Optium results demonstrated within 15% and 20% accuracy compared to the other meter systems. The HDI True Track was significantly less precise than the other meter systems. Conclusions: The Abbott Optium was significantly more accurate than the other meter systems, whereas the HDI True Track was significantly less accurate and less precise compared to the other meter systems.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Business InformationEndocrine Practice, 2007
- The role of self-monitoring of blood glucose in the care of people with diabetes: report of a global consensus conferenceThe American Journal of Medicine, 2005
- Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Who Are Not Using InsulinDiabetes Care, 2005
- Home Blood Glucose Prediction: Validation, Safety, and Efficacy Testing in Clinical DiabetesDiabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2005
- Standards of Medical Care in DiabetesDiabetes Care, 2004
- The Treat-to-Target TrialDiabetes Care, 2003
- Additional Lunchtime Basal Insulin During Insulin Lispro Intensive Therapy in a Randomized, Multicenter, Crossover Study in AdultsDiabetes Care, 2002
- Self-Monitoring of Blood GlucoseDiabetes Care, 1994
- The Effect of Intensive Treatment of Diabetes on the Development and Progression of Long-Term Complications in Insulin-Dependent Diabetes MellitusNew England Journal of Medicine, 1993
- Evaluating Clinical Accuracy of Systems for Self-Monitoring of Blood GlucoseDiabetes Care, 1987