Human Rights and Decision-making in Child Protection through Explicit Argumentation
Authors:
- Joe DuffyJDJoe Duffy
- Brian TaylorBTBrian Taylor
- Susannah Mc CallSCSusannah Mc Call
- 1 April 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Child Care in Practice
- Vol. 12 (2) , 81-95
Abstract
A recent judgement in February 2005 by the Lord Chief Justice in Northern Ireland that a Health and Social Services Trust had breached a parent's Article 8 Right to Family Life in the process used to take a young child into care has stimulated major debate about the interface between the Human Rights Act (1998) and professional decision-making in child protection work in Northern Ireland and across Europe. This article examines the interface between the Human Rights Act and the paramountcy principle in the Children (NI) Order 1995 in relation to statutory interventions to protect children. It explores the increasing sophistication required of social work recommendations to courts in complex situations involving conflicting rights and considers the impact of adopting a structured model of explicit argumentation.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- The development of practice theory in adult protection intervention: insights from a recent research projectThe Journal of Adult Protection, 2005
- Social Work Education and criticality: some thoughts from researchSocial Work Education, 2004
- Moral Consciousness and Decision-Making in Child and Family Social WorkAdoption & Fostering, 2003
- The need for explicit argumentation in ethical decision-making in social workSocial Work Education, 2001
- The Human Rights Act and social work practicePractice, 2001
- An Introduction to Working with Children2001
- Professional Ethics in Social Work-- What Future?The British Journal of Social Work, 1998
- Ethical dilemmas in practice -some thoughts on the children (ni) orderChild Care in Practice, 1995
- Ethics and Values in Social Work1995
- Cognitive-Behavior Modification1977