Could sex be maintained through harmful males?
Abstract
All else being equal, parthenogenetic females should produce as many surviving daughters as sexual couples produce daughters plus sons. Hence the resources spent on producing sons are a cost of sex and parthenogenetic females economize on sons. It has recently been shown that a small competitive advantage of sexual individuals can recoup this large reproductive disadvantage, while the adaptation behind the competitive advantage might differ from case to case. One hypothesis that has not yet been considered as a potential competitive advantage is that males could differentially harm parthenogenetic females, for example, through harassment, toxic seminal fluids, or infanticide. Harmful male functions result from the selection for males that maximise their fitness at the expense of females in the context of sexual conflict. Unless parthenogenetic lineages can maintain their resistance against harmful male functions, a competitive advantage for sex should be a by‐product benefit of sexual conflict. Mutations that make males harm parthenogenetic females worse than sexual ones, however, can be seen as evolutionary spite. The spiteful trait is not the production of costly sons, but the production of males that discriminate against parthenogenetic females. Spiteful behaviour can be positively selected, if it acts against negatively related victims. Sexual and parthenogenetic individuals within a population should usually be negatively related, because the genomes of the sexual individuals are bound together by recombination while those of parthenogenetic individuals will be identical except for divergence through mutation. Some unusual cases of parthenogenesis are discussed in the light of this new hypothesis and an experimental approach for testing it is suggested.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Distribution and stability of supernumerary microchromosomes in natural populations of the Amazon molly, Poecilia formosaCytogenetic and Genome Research, 2004
- FEMALE RESISTANCE TO MALE HARM EVOLVES IN RESPONSE TO MANIPULATION OF SEXUAL CONFLICTEvolution, 2004
- Precopulatory mate guarding and mating behaviour in the rotiferEpiphanes senta(Monogononta: Rotifera)Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 2003
- Spite: altruism's evil twinOikos, 2003
- Dynamics of regional coexistence for more or less equal competitorsJournal of Animal Ecology, 2003
- Altruistic sperm donation in a sperm‐dependent parthenogenetic hermaphrodite is stabilized by reciprocal sperm exchangeJournal of Zoology, 2003
- The Survival of Slow ReproducersJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2000
- Why sex? A parody on the paradoxOikos, 2000
- Evolutionary genetics and ecology of sperm‐dependent parthenogenesisJournal of Evolutionary Biology, 1998
- Incorporation of subgenomic amounts of DNA as compensation for mutational load in a gynogenetic fishNature, 1995