Lesbian women disrupting gendered, heteronormative discourses of motherhood, marriage, and divorce
- 27 May 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Lesbian Studies
- Vol. 24 (1) , 12-24
Abstract
Despite shifts in societal attitudes, lesbian women who separate and divorce still must cope with recriminating societal messages that blame and condemn them for not conforming to the gendered heteronormative dictate of married motherhood. Guided by feminist theory, we conducted a qualitative analysis of narratives from 17 adoptive lesbian mothers who had dissolved their relationship. The women’s narratives revealed five cultural discourses that they variously embraced, resisted, or disrupted: (1) the ideology of the good mother; (2) divorce is bad for children; (3) marriage is the ideal way to live; (4) couples should stay together for the children; and (5) lesbian ex-lovers should be lifelong friends. All women embraced the cultural belief in “the good mother,” which is the linchpin of gendered oppression, but they were much more disruptive regarding the remaining four discourses surrounding marriage, divorce, and lesbian relationships. Their assessments of life after separation revealed that divorce can actually be better than marriage for their children; marriage is often overrated; having children can complicate a marriage; and remaining friends with one’s ex-partner is not always desirable. The feminist tenet that oppression and agency coexist was revealed as the women both engaged and resisted dominant cultural narratives in order to navigate the dilemmas of crafting a new life for themselves and their children post-divorce.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Three critical questions for future research on lesbian relationshipsJournal of Lesbian Studies, 2016
- “The Secret of Our Success”: Long-term Same-Sex Couples' Perceptions of Their Relationship LongevityJournal of GLBT Family Studies, 2016
- Predictors of relationship dissolution in lesbian, gay, and heterosexual adoptive parents.Journal of Family Psychology, 2015
- Lesbian and Heterosexual Adoptive Mothers’ Experiences of Relationship DissolutionSex Roles, 2014
- An Overview of Same-Sex Couples in Relation Ships: A Research Area Still at Sea2009
- Reclaiming Feminist Theory, Method, and Praxis for Family Studies2009
- Ambiguous Loss Theory: Challenges for Scholars and PractitionersFamily Relations, 2007
- Lesbian Ex-Lover RelationshipsJournal of Lesbian Studies, 2004
- The Rhetoric of Motives in DivorceJournal of Marriage and Family, 1993
- Lesbian Mothers and the Motherhood HierarchyJournal of Homosexuality, 1989