Humans are an interdependent species with a fundamental need for belonging. Threats to belonging, such as social exclusion, alter how individuals interpret information in their social environments. Faces are amongst the most critical of these cues, with perceived facial trustworthiness and emotion expressions serving as signals for rapidly inferring others’ intentions and likely behavior. Prior literature demonstrates that exclusion and facial trustworthiness separately influence emotion recognition, but no prior work has tested whether they interact to shape emotion recognition. The present studies first tested whether exclusion altered facial trustworthiness judgments, then tested whether exclusion and facial trustworthiness predicted emotion recognition and mislabeling of emotionally neutral faces. Resting parasympathetic cardiac control was examined as an individual difference moderator. Findings provide little evidence that exclusion altered facial trustworthiness judgments. Facial trustworthiness cues systematically shaped emotion recognition in an emotion-specific rather than uniformly threat- or affiliation-congruent manner. Social exclusion showed narrower effects, selectively reducing recognition of sad expressions, but provided little evidence for broader changes in the extent to which facial trustworthiness informed emotion recognition. Higher parasympathetic cardiac control was associated with lower fear recognition in included participants only. Finally, facial trustworthiness, but not exclusion, influenced mislabeling of emotionally neutral faces: highly trustworthy faces were more likely to be mislabeled as happy and surprised, whereas untrustworthy faces were more likely to be mislabeled as disgusted. Together, these findings suggest that facial trustworthiness shapes emotion recognition and neutral-face mislabeling in emotion-specific ways, whereas the effects of exclusion and parasympathetic cardiac control are more selective.