Abstract
Tropical systems, particularly soil microbial communities in tropical soils, have received disproportionately little study compared to their temperate and continental counterparts. In addition, so-called 'helicopter research', where research teams entirely from boreal and temperate areas have conducted empirical work in tropical countries without including local scientists, appears vulnerable to oversights that stem from intuitions ill-calibrated to the study systems. One such intuition, we argue, is that tropical systems are 'exotic' and thus require explanation, inferentially speaking, relative to the 'norm' of boreal and temperate systems. This framing and empirical knowledge gap risk compromising our mechanistic understanding of soil organic carbon (SOC) cycling, because ecological, thermodynamic and biochemical theory point to differences in kind, not just degree, of SOC protection pathways in tropical soils. In fact, tropical soils operate so close to the temperature optima of microbial physiology and enzyme activities, that they may be framed as the 'norm' for inferential purposes, compared to which soil microbes in seasonal ecosystems exist in an almost continuous state of cold stress. Much of what is observed in these cooler soils thus may reflect adaptations to cold stress rather than generalisable mechanisms of SOC cycling and persistence. Given the enormous quantity (and global fraction) of carbon fluxing through the terrestrial tropics, this geographic bias and its attendant risks to understanding deserve urgent attention, both through increased research focus as well as co-design with local scientists. Like the shift from geocentrism to heliocentrism, inverting the baseline to the tropics may be the simplest path to a parsimonious theory of SOC persistence that holds across the full range of the world's soils, one that depends, in turn, on input from the full range of the world's scientists.

This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit: