Impact of (forensic) expert opinions according to the Istanbul Protocol in Germany—results and insights of the in:Fo-project
Authors:
Open Access
- 14 February 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International journal of legal medicine
- Vol. 137 (3) , 863-873
Abstract
As part of a third-party funded project, expert opinions according to the Istanbul Protocol (IP) standards were compiled in Germany on a larger scale for the first time. The assessment process was initiated for 130 project participants. Statistical analysis on numerous variables was performed to test the impact of the expert opinions, foremost of the forensic medical expert opinions, on the individuals’ asylum proceedings. The variables were drawn from forensic medical expert opinions and reports of findings, questionnaires for the study participants’ counsellors in the project and a query on the asylum status of the study participants. Regression analysis and bivariate analysis on two dependent variables—subjective impact on the asylum procedure from the counsellors’ point of view and objective change in the asylum status—were performed to test for an influence on asylum procedures. No statistically significant results were obtained for the objective change of the study participants’ asylum status. For the subjective dependent variable, a positive prediction was possible when simultaneously controlling for the independent variables introduction of a forensic medical expert opinion and highest IP grade; a negative prediction was possible when simultaneously controlling for the independent variables introduction of a forensic medical expert opinion and use of IP grading. Apart from the statistical analysis, a positive effect of the assessment on the psychosocial well-being of the study participants could be demonstrated. The results differed from other European studies which demonstrated a correlation between the objective outcome of an asylum procedure (asylum status) and, for example, specific types of violence or the number of documented injuries. Differences also occurred in the use of the plausibility grades proposed by the IP, which questions their use in cases in which the reported torture happened a relevant time ago. Therefore, compiling individually worded evaluations instead of using the IP grading system—if possible, by an experienced forensic physician—is recommended in this scenario. Still, the assessment of alleged torture experiences should follow the IP guidelines, since psychological assessments are of especially high importance in cases with healed physical injuries and since the results also demonstrated a positive effect on the psychosocial well-being of the study participants.Keywords
Funding Information
- Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund (AM17-NW3345)
- Heinrich-Heine-Universität Düsseldorf
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Asylrechtliche Aspekte von Folter Asylum rights aspects of tortureRechtsmedizin, 2017
- Asylum seekers alleging torture in their countries: Evaluation of a French centerJournal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 2017
- The Istanbul protocol (manual on the effective investigation and documentation of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment): implementation and education in Israel.2014
- The role of doctors in investigation, prevention and treatment of tortureJournal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 2012
- Medical forensic examination of detained immigrants: is the Istanbul Protocol followed?Medicine, Science and the Law, 2012
- Implementation of Istanbul Protocol for effective documentation of torture – review of Sri Lankan perspectivesJournal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 2011
- Documentation of torture and the Istanbul Protocol: applied medical ethicsMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2010
- Asylum Grant Rates Following Medical Evaluations of Maltreatment among Political Asylum Applicants in the United StatesJournal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 2007
- Documentation of torture victims, assessment of the start procedure for medico-legal documentation.2007
- Documentation of torture victims. Implementation of medico-legal protocols.2007