Critical Questions and Argument Stratagems: A Framework for Enhancing and Analyzing Students' Reasoning Practices
- 19 April 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of the Learning Sciences
- Vol. 20 (3) , 443-488
Abstract
This article explores the concepts of critical questions (from D. N. Walton, 1996 Walton, D. N. 1996. Argument schemes for presumptive reasoning, Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum. [Google Scholar] ) and integrative and refutational argument stratagems as an approach for teaching argumentation and critical thinking. A study was conducted for 6 months in 3 sections of a 7th-grade social studies classroom in which 30 students discussed and wrote about current events. One section served as a comparison group. Over time the experimental group made more arguments that integrated both sides of each issue. Collectively, the experimental group also successfully constructed salient critical questions, particularly in regard to weighing values and designing practical creative solutions. In-depth analysis of 1 student showed how conceptual structures and argument practices improved incrementally over time and how the appropriation of stratagems may have been facilitated by the dialectical nature of the intervention (e.g., using critical questions and stratagems successfully in discourse). The theoretical and practical importance of Walton's dialogue theory, and the critical question approach to argumentation, are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Supporting Argumentation Through Students' Questions: Case Studies in Science ClassroomsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 2010
- A Note from the EditorCognition and Instruction, 2008
- The effects of monological and dialogical argumentation on concept learning in evolutionary theory.Journal of Educational Psychology, 2007
- Prompting Middle School Science Students for Productive Reflection: Generic and Directed PromptsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 2003
- Fourth and Fifth Graders Representing the Argument Structure in Written TextsDiscourse Processes, 2002
- The Snowball Phenomenon: Spread of Ways of Talking and Ways of Thinking Across Groups of ChildrenCognition and Instruction, 2001
- Training in Self-Explanation and Self-Regulation Strategies: Investigating the Effects of Knowledge Acquisition Activities on Problem SolvingCognition and Instruction, 1995
- Design Experiments: Theoretical and Methodological Challenges in Creating Complex Interventions in Classroom SettingsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 1992
- Contributing to DiscourseCognitive Science, 1989
- From Axiom to Dialogue1982