Is a verification phase needed to determine $ {\dot{\text{V}}} $O2max across fitness levels?

Authors:

Abstract
Introduction Current methods (plateau/secondary criteria) to determine maximal oxygen consumption (\( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2max) are inconsistently achieved leading some to suggest the use of a verification phase (VP) to confirm \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2max. Purpose To provide further evidence for the inclusion of a VP to confirm \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2max in different fitness levels. Methods Forty-nine participants (22 females; 21.9 ± 2.6 years, 24.3 ± 2.8 kg m−2, 45.27 ± 7.68 mL kg−1 min−1) had their \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2 and heart rate measured during three graded exercise tests (GXT) on separate days each followed by a VP of differing intensity (85%, 95%, 105% final workload). Participants were divided into groups using norms adapted from American College of Sports Medicine \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2max guidelines (30.47–61.47 mL kg−1 min−1). \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2max was confirmed if the \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2peak on the VP or an additional GXT was within ± 2 × typical error of the \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2peak attained on the first GXT. There was no effect of test number so the third GXT was not included in comparison with VP. Results The \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2peak from the first GXT was not different than either value attained following the VP at 95 or 105% workload or a second GXT (p > 0.999). The 85% VP \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2peak was lower than the first GXT \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2peak (p = 0.002). The VP confirmed the GXT \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2peak on 73% of VP (no differences among fitness levels). Submaximal VP (85 and 95%) was less effective as 65% and 51% of participants achieved a higher \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2peak on one of the GXT. Conclusion The use of a VP at 105% or a second GXT was able to confirm the \( {\dot{\text{V}}} \)O2max value attained across a range of fitness levels.

This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit: