Theory Construction in SLA
Author:
- 1 June 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Studies in Second Language Acquisition
- Vol. 13 (4) , 493-511
Abstract
There are indications that a determined effort toward theory construction is currently being mounted in SLA (Gregg, 1989, 1990; Long, 1990; Spolsky, 1989). This raises a number of epistemological issues, one of which is the question of multiple theories and lack of convergence (and the related question of distinguishing science from nonscience–and from nonsense). In a field where there are many different therorise, is the relationship between them one of complementarity or of opposition? Are there criteria for appraisal and choice? Issues relating to theory construction have received considerable attention in the literature (e.g., Lightbown, 1984; McLaughlin, 1987). This article aims to build on such initiative asking: (a) Are there multiple theories of SLA? (b) Is it a problem? and (c) what criteria have SLA researchers used to appraise and choose between theories, and how compelling are they? Following this, consideration is given to top-down and bottom-up approaches to SLA theory construction. I conclude by advancing the modest claim that rationality in SLA therory construction is possible, in spite of insistent problems.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Least a Second Language Acquisition Theory Needs to ExplainTESOL Quarterly, 1990
- Replication in Applied Linguistics ResearchTESOL Quarterly, 1989
- Dominance and the Disunity of Method: Solving the Problems of Innovation and ConsensusPhilosophy of Science, 1989
- Classroom Research in Second Language AcquisitionAnnual Review of Applied Linguistics, 1989
- Against Comprehensible Input: the Input Hypothesis and the Development of Second-language CompetenceApplied Linguistics, 1987
- Comments on Bernard A. Mohan and Winnie Au-Yeung Lo's "Academic Writing and Chinese Students: Transfer and Developmental Factors". Response to Ricento: On Hypotheses in Cross-Cultural Rhetoric ResearchTESOL Quarterly, 1986
- A POETICS OF SECOND‐LANGUAGE ACQUISITION1Language Learning, 1979
- OPERATING PRINCIPLES AND ‘UNIVERSALS’ IN L1, L2, AND FLTInternational Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching, 1979
- GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF NEUROFUNCTIONAL ORGANIZATION AND THEIR MANIFESTATION IN PRIMARY AND NONPRIMARY LANGUAGE ACQUISITION1Language Learning, 1977
- Beyond the two disciplines of scientific psychology.American Psychologist, 1975