Teaching self-criticism and peer-critique skills to engineering students through a temporal survey-based program
Open Access
- 3 May 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 9, 1399750
Abstract
Introduction: Engineering students should develop critical-thinking skills and insist on appropriate performance levels both from themselves and from their colleagues during their training. In doing so, they will adopt critical attitudes toward their own and others’ work. This will help them to successfully perform their future professional work with the highest standards.Methods: In this research, peer- and self-assessments of in-class presentations through a survey-based program were used to analyze the development of critical-thinking skills among engineering students. The program included two key features: firstly, formative assessments were repeatedly conducted over time; secondly, teachers’ ratings were provided to students as comparative benchmarks. This approach encouraged students to reflect on their ratings over time using the reference of the teacher.Results: From a general perspective, the analysis of survey responses showed that students assigned lower ratings in assessments conducted at a later stage, despite receiving higher ratings from their teachers over time. Therefore, students became more demanding throughout the experience in spite of the increased quality of their work according to the teachers’ assessments. Moreover, students tended to closely attune their evaluations to their teachers’ ratings. Comparing peer- and self-assessments, it was noted that students were more demanding toward the work of their peers in the long term, and especially their ability to explain concepts, than they were toward their own work. Nevertheless, high temporary increases were observed in students’ own self-assessments of presentation-file quality. Finally, students did not conduct overall assessments with the same level of demand as their teachers at any time during the experience.Discussion: The results demonstrate that this program and similar initiatives are useful to help engineering students to develop critical-thinking skills and to broaden their expectations with respect to their own and their colleagues’ work. However, other relevant aspects could be evaluated in lengthier programs, such as whether the students’ levels of critical thinking and expectations are maintained when the comparative reference of a teacher’s assessment is unavailable.Keywords
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Toward artificially intelligent cloud-based building information modelling for collaborative multidisciplinary designAdvanced Engineering Informatics, 2022
- A team‐oriented course development experience in distance education for multidisciplinary engineering designComputer Applications in Engineering Education, 2022
- Linking Engineering Students’ Professional Identity Development to Diversity and Working Inclusively in Technical CoursesJournal of Civil Engineering Education, 2021
- Connecting Activity Implementation Characteristics to Student Buy-In Toward and Utilization of Formative Assessments Within Undergraduate Biology CoursesJournal for STEM Education Research, 2021
- Is learning scale-free? Chemistry learning increases EEG fractal power and changes the power law exponentNeuroscience Research, 2020
- An investigation into factors causing delays in highway construction projects in iraqMATEC Web of Conferences, 2018
- Does peer assessment in on-line learning environments work? A systematic review of the literatureComputers in Human Behavior, 2016
- A Learning Attitude Evaluation System for Learning Concentration on Distance EducationLecture Notes in Computer Science, 2006
- Criticism: a relatively neglected area in engineering teacher training programmesEngineering Science & Education Journal, 1999
- Course evaluation and attitudes toward college teachingHigher Education, 1983