Mismatch or misunderstanding? Calculation and qualculation among economists and consumers in their framings of the electricity market
Authors:
- 22 September 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Acta Sociologica
- Vol. 59 (4) , 347-361
Abstract
This paper reports on a study of how economists engaged in energy policymaking and household consumers frame the electricity market, based on interviews with prominent energy economists and focus group interviews with household consumers. Drawing on economic sociology, and above all the contribution of Michel Callon, we analyse framing processes involved in the sense-making with regard to the electricity market, including electricity consumption and the understanding of how households act with respect to the market. It was found that the economists drew predominantly on a framing of the electricity market according to their theoretical understanding of markets, considering consumers as calculative agents in a strict sense. In contrast, the consumers argued a more inclusive and complex framing of the electricity market by also emphasising moral, social and political issues. Thus, the consumers appeared to be qualculative rather than just calculative agents. This different framing did not emerge from consumers’ misunderstandings or their being misinformed about market mechanisms. Rather, we observed a mismatch between the energy economists and the household consumers regarding the underlying rationality of their framings, how they perceived consumption of electricity, and what they included and excluded in the framing of the market.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Energy cultures: A framework for understanding energy behavioursEnergy Policy, 2010
- The devil is in the details: Household electricity saving behavior and the role of informationEnergy Policy, 2010
- Residential heat comfort practices: understanding usersBuilding Research & Information, 2010
- On the emergence of roles in construction: the qualculative role of project managementConstruction Management and Economics, 2009
- Comfort in a lower carbon societyBuilding Research & Information, 2008
- Energy comes homeEnergy Policy, 2007
- Theories of Markets and Theories of SocietyAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 2007
- Economic Sociology and the Social Problem of Energy InefficiencyAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 2007
- On Qualculation, Agency, and OthernessEnvironment and Planning D: Society and Space, 2005
- Why Has Critique Run out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of ConcernCritical Inquiry, 2004