Reading from computer screen versus reading from paper: does it still make a difference?
Authors:
- 13 November 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Ergonomics
- Vol. 59 (5) , 615-632
Abstract
Four experiments were conducted to test whether recent developments in display technology would suffice to eliminate the well-known disadvantages in reading from screen as compared with paper. Proofreading speed and performance were equal for a TFT-LCD and a paper display, but there were more symptoms of eyestrain in the screen condition accompanied by a strong preference for paper (Experiment 1). These results were replicated using a longer reading duration (Experiment 2). Additional experiments were conducted to test hypotheses about the reasons for the higher amount of eyestrain associated with reading from screen. Reduced screen luminance did not change the pattern of results (Experiment 3), but positioning both displays in equal inclination angles eliminated the differences in eyestrain symptoms and increased proofreading speed in the screen condition (Experiment 4). A paper-like positioning of TFT-LCDs seems to enable unimpaired reading without evidence of increased physical strain. Practitioner Summary: Given the developments in screen technology, a re-assessment of the differences in proofreading speed and performance, well-being, and preference between computer screen and paper was conducted. State-of-the-art TFT-LCDs enable unimpaired reading, but a book-like positioning of screens seems necessary to minimise eyestrain symptoms.Keywords
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Subjective Impressions Do Not Mirror Online Reading Effort: Concurrent EEG-Eyetracking Evidence from the Reading of Books and Digital MediaPLOS ONE, 2013
- ClearType sub-pixel text rendering: Preference, legibility and reading performanceDisplays, 2008
- CRT versus LCD: effects of refresh rate, display technology and background luminance in visual performanceDisplays, 2001
- CRT versus LCD: A pilot study on visual performance and suitability of two display technologies for use in office workDisplays, 1999
- Analysis of ocular surface area for comfortable VDT workstation layoutErgonomics, 1996
- Musculoskeletal disorders among visual display terminal workers: individual, ergonomic, and work organizational factorsErgonomics, 1995
- Reading performance and visual comfort with scale to grey compared with black-and-white scanned printDisplays, 1994
- Reading and skimming from computer screens and books: the paperless office revisited?Behaviour & Information Technology, 1991
- Proof-reading: VDU and paper text compared for speed, accuracy and fatigueBehaviour & Information Technology, 1987
- Proof-reading on VDUsBehaviour & Information Technology, 1987