Use of Multiple-Choice Items in Summative Examinations: Questionnaire Survey Among German Undergraduate Dental Training Programs
Open Access
- 27 June 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Medical Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , e58126
Abstract
Background: Multiple-choice examinations are frequently used in German dental schools. However, details regarding the used item types and applied scoring methods are lacking. Objective: This study aims to gain insight into the current use of multiple-choice items (ie, questions) in summative examinations in German undergraduate dental training programs. Methods: A paper-based 10-item questionnaire regarding the used assessment methods, multiple-choice item types, and applied scoring methods was designed. The pilot-tested questionnaire was mailed to the deans of studies and to the heads of the Department of Operative/Restorative Dentistry at all 30 dental schools in Germany in February 2023. Statistical analysis was performed using the Fisher exact test (P<.05). Results: The response rate amounted to 90% (27/30 dental schools). All respondent dental schools used multiple-choice examinations for summative assessments. Examinations were delivered electronically by 70% (19/27) of the dental schools. Almost all dental schools used single-choice Type A items (24/27, 89%), which accounted for the largest number of items in approximately half of the dental schools (13/27, 48%). Further item types (eg, conventional multiple-select items, Multiple-True-False, and Pick-N) were only used by fewer dental schools (≤67%, up to 18 out of 27 dental schools). For the multiple-select item types, the applied scoring methods varied considerably (ie, awarding [intermediate] partial credit and requirements for partial credit). Dental schools with the possibility of electronic examinations used multiple-select items slightly more often (14/19, 74% vs 4/8, 50%). However, this difference was statistically not significant (P=.38). Dental schools used items either individually or as key feature problems consisting of a clinical case scenario followed by a number of items focusing on critical treatment steps (15/27, 56%). Not a single school used alternative testing methods (eg, answer-until-correct). A formal item review process was established at about half of the dental schools (15/27, 56%). Conclusions: Summative assessment methods among German dental schools vary widely. Especially, a large variability regarding the use and scoring of multiple-select multiple-choice items was found.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Scoring Single-Response Multiple-Choice Items: Scoping Review and Comparison of Different Scoring MethodsJMIR Medical Education, 2023
- Use of Multiple-Select Multiple-Choice Items in a Dental Undergraduate Curriculum: Retrospective Study Involving the Application of Different Scoring MethodsJMIR Medical Education, 2023
- Relation between examinees’ true knowledge and examination scores: systematic review and exemplary calculations on Pick-N itemsEducational Research Review, 2022
- Relation between examinees’ true knowledge and examination scores: systematic review and exemplary calculations on Multiple-True-False itemsEducational Research Review, 2021
- Prüfen mit Multiple Choice2019
- Effect of different scoring approaches upon credit assignment when using Multiple True‐False items in dental undergraduate examinationsEuropean Journal of Dental Education, 2018
- Gutachten zur Erstellung „gerichtsfester” Multiple-Choice-PrüfungsaufgabenPsychologische Rundschau, 2014
- Pick-N multiple choice-exams: a comparison of scoring algorithmsAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2010
- Comparative Reliabilities of Five Types of Objective Examinations.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1925
- The Kansas Silent Reading Tests.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1916