External Source Monitoring and Reality Monitoring: Meta‐Analysis of fMRI Studies
Open Access
- 29 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Human Brain Mapping
- Vol. 47 (11)
Abstract
Being able to remember the origin of a particular memory is for times even more important than the memory itself. Yet, although memory for the information and memory for the source are intrinsically connected, the particular neural underpinnings for the source‐memory monitoring remains unclear. We run an fMRI meta‐analysis to help to clarify the brain structures necessary for source memory monitoring. Source monitoring (SM) relates to distinguishing the origin of the information of two external sources, whereas reality monitoring (RM) refers to distinguishing between one internal (e.g., thoughts) and one external source, or two internal sources. We used PRISMA to select the manuscripts and Ginger ALE to analyze the data of the final 51 eligible selected articles. Most of the articles referred to external SM paradigms (34), but the number of articles on RM (17) allowed us to run a separate analysis to identify brain regions active during this specific process. The SM and RM contrasts showed concordance in 10 clusters, being the largest cluster with the highest ALE value found in the left claustrum and middle Frontal Gyrus (BA 46, 9 and 10). SM contrasts show concordance in seven clusters that include the largest cluster centered in the left middle frontal (BA 9) and inferior frontal gyrus (BA 45). Five suprathreshold clusters were detected for RM contrasts. The largest one was detected in the parietal lobe, centered in the left inferior parietal lobule (BA 40) and left angular gyrus (BA 39). The results support the neural differentiation, as well as a partial overlapping, for the two different types of monitoring. Moreover, they help to understand the divergent results in fMRI studies most likely due to the stimuli characteristics.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE‐BR‐2025‐26)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Unraveling the brain mechanisms of source monitoring with non-invasive brain stimulation: A systematic reviewInternational Journal of Clinical and Health Psychology, 2024
- The neural signature of reality‐monitoring: A meta‐analysis of functional neuroimaging studiesHuman Brain Mapping, 2023
- Hippocampal spatial view cells for memory and navigation, and their underlying connectivity in humansHippocampus, 2022
- An integrative model of network activity during episodic memory retrieval and a meta-analysis of fMRI studies on source memory retrievalBrain Research, 2020
- Neurofunctional correlates of body-ownership and sense of agency: A meta-analytical account of self-consciousnessCortex, 2019
- Implementation errors in the GingerALE Software: Description and recommendationsHuman Brain Mapping, 2016
- Specific marker of feigned memory impairment: The activation of left superior frontal gyrusJournal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 2015
- Minimizing within‐experiment and within‐group effects in activation likelihood estimation meta‐analysesHuman Brain Mapping, 2011
- Source Monitoring2008
- Domain‐specific impairment of source memory following a right posterior medial temporal lobe lesionHippocampus, 2007