The importance of experimental design in detecting the effects of protection measures on fish in Mediterranean MPAs
Author:
- 19 June 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems
- Vol. 12 (6) , 619-634
Abstract
Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) are currently proliferating in the Mediterranean Sea. The assessment of their role in the protection and recovery of overexploited fish populations, however, is not yet completely supported by an adequate body of scientific evidence. This is in part because the number of studies that unambiguously assess changes induced by protection is limited. Sampling to detect and measure the expected effects of protection on commercial fish (e.g. increase in mean abundance and size) is made difficult by intrinsic natural spatial and temporal variability. Ideally, temporal replication before and after the establishment of MPAs is necessary for estimating the average conditions in time. Spatial replication of control locations, on the other hand, is essential to prevent confusion in interpreting a difference between protected and unprotected locations. Until now, the basic requirements for appropriate experimental designs in MPAs were seldom satisfied, especially in the Mediterranean region. In the present paper, an ideal experimental design aimed at overcoming many of the confounding influences that could result in misinterpretations of the results is considered, with a discussion of implications of applying less and less appropriate designs because of pragmatic constraints. Experimental design should thus be adapted to each individual MPA under study on the basis of the specific constraints that researchers face (e.g. ‘before’ (i.e. pre‐designation) data are lacking; there is a single or more than one protected locations). The issues related to MPAs, chiefly in the Mediterranean region, need to be considered to enable the identification of unambiguous hypotheses prior to sampling, based on clear logical structures. The importance of appropriate sampling and the subsequent interpretation of data would progressively reduce the degree of uncertainty of environmental analyses about the effects of MPAs on fish, with important implications for their management and further proliferation. Copyright © 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- BEYOND BACI: OPTIMIZATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SAMPLING DESIGNS THROUGH MONITORING AND SIMULATIONEcological Applications, 2001
- Cultural and socio-economic impacts of Mediterranean marine protected areasEnvironmental Conservation, 2000
- MARINE RESERVES ARE NECESSARY BUT NOT SUFFICIENT FOR MARINE CONSERVATIONEcological Applications, 1998
- Short term monitoring of biotic change in Tasmanian marine reservesJournal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 1997
- Variability at different spatial scales between a subtidal assemblage exposed to the discharge of sewage and two control assemblagesJournal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 1995
- Study of a Mediterranean reef fish assemblage. Comparisons of population distributions between depths in protected and unprotected areas over one decadeAquatic Living Resources, 1995
- Fluctuations and Variations in Coastal Marine EnvironmentsMarine Ecology, 1994
- Implications of ‘supply-side’ ecology for environmental assessment and managementTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 1991
- The consequences of variation in initial settlement vs. post-settlement mortality in rocky intertidal communitiesJournal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 1985
- Effects of Depth and Marine Reserve Fishing Restrictions on the Structure of a Rocky Reef Fish Assemblage in the North-Western Mediterranean SeaJournal of Applied Ecology, 1983