Comparison of GaN FET and Si MOSFET based vienna rectifiers

Authors:

Abstract
As the technology on wide bandgap materials such as gallium-nitride (GaN) has advanced rapidly, commercial GaN power devices with satisfying performance are available now. It is widely-known that GaN-based switching devices have several advantages over traditional Si-based switching devices, such as lower ON-resistance, faster switching speed, better thermal conductivity, and smaller size. However, researchers have not yet fully explored and applied GaN devices in some of the important power conversion applications. In this paper, a popular three-phase three-level three-switch Vienna rectifier is designed with GaN FETs. The advantages and challenges of utilizing GaN FETs in Vienna rectifiers are discussed. The topology, control and simulation are carried out as well. To provide a comparative analysis of the GaN FET and Si MOSFET based Vienna rectifiers, two prototypes are built with each type of the power devices on a similar scale. Detailed comparative analysis discussions based on the experimental results, including size, power circuit efficiency and THD, are provided. It is concluded in this paper that GaN FETs and their drivers have smaller size and higher power density compared with Si MOSFETs and their drivers. The overall performance of the GaN FET and Si MOSFET based Vienna rectifiers are at the same level, although driving techniques of the GaN FET devices are not mature.