The role of adaptive and innovative trial designs in diabetes research: A scoping review

Authors:
  • AGAshni Goshrani
    Ashni Goshrani
  • RLRose Lin
    Rose Lin
  • MGMichele Gaca
    Michele Gaca
  • CSChristine Somerville
    Christine Somerville
  • KKKamlesh Khunti
    Kamlesh Khunti
  • EHElizabeth Holmes-Truscott
    Elizabeth Holmes-Truscott
  • NNNegar Naderpoor
    Negar Naderpoor
  • DODavid O’Neal
    David O’Neal
  • LCLeonid Churilov
    Leonid Churilov
  • RHRury Holman
    Rury Holman
  • EEElif Ekinci
    Elif Ekinci

Abstract
Background: Adaptive and master protocol clinical trials offer significant advantages for diabetes research, including enhanced efficiency and personalized treatment strategies. Purpose: This scoping review aimed to systematically map the use of adaptive and master protocol designs in interventional trials for type 1 and type 2 diabetes, identify research gaps and highlight opportunities for broader implementation.Data Sources: A systematic literature search was performed using MEDLINE, Embase, CENTRAL, Emcare, Global Health, Web of Science, and clinical trial registries. Grey literature searches complemented database findings. Study Selection: Studies using adaptive, platform, basket, or umbrella trial designs in people with type 1 or type 2 diabetes were included.Data Extraction: Data were charted using a standardized form. Extracted variables included diabetes type, trial design, adaptive features, interventions, endpoints, and key findings.Data Synthesis: Of 396 articles screened, six published adaptive trials met inclusion criteria: three in type 1 diabetes, one in type 2 diabetes, and two in diabetes-related neuropathy. Most used adaptive features for dose-finding, response-adaptive randomisation and sample size re-estimation. No published platform, basket, or umbrella trials were identified. Six ongoing adaptive trials in type 1 diabetes were identified through registry searches, four under an adaptive platform master protocol.Limitations: Despite a comprehensive search, some grey literature and unpublished studies may have been missed. Risk of bias was not assessed, consistent with scoping review methodology. Conclusions: Adaptive and master protocol trials remain rare in diabetes. Overcoming barriers through targeted training and awareness, robust regulatory frameworks, and strategic incentives could support broader adoption.
All Related Versions