Foundational issues: how must global ethics be global?
Author:
- 2 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Global Ethics
- Vol. 10 (1) , 16-25
Abstract
Over the past 20 years, global ethics has come to be conceived in different ways. Two main tendencies can be distinguished. One asks from whence global ethics comes and defines ‘global ethics’ as arising from globalization. The other tendency is to ask whither global ethics must go and thus defines ‘global ethics’ as a destination, namely arriving at a comprehensive global ethic. I will note some types of discussion that may have been wrongly excluded from the scope of global ethics by one or the other. In addition, I take notice of recent debates and concerns about risks that global ethics may become a neo-colonial activity. These concerns raise a further conceptual question. Should ‘global ethics’ be defined in a normative fashion, so as to exclude neo-colonial approaches that may be damaging to the credibility of global ethics? In response to these alternatives – whence vs. whither, descriptive vs. normative – I will propose a middle way. I begin by defining ‘global problems’ as those that will cause harm in the absence of cross-border cooperation. In a descriptive sense, any ethical statements about global problems should be included within the scope of global ethics. On the other hand, I will propose a more specific normative conception of the central task of global ethics: seeking reasonable and responsible agreement on global problems, agreement based on possibly diverse moral grounds.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- GLOBAL ETHICS AND HUMAN RIGHTS: A REFLECTIONJournal of Religious Ethics, 2011
- Development Ethics2011
- National responsibility, reparations and distributive justiceCritical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, 2008
- Introduction: The Globalization of Ethics2007
- IS GLOBAL ETHICS MORAL NEO‐COLONIALISM? AN INVESTIGATION OF THE ISSUE IN THE CONTEXT OF BIOETHICSBioethics, 2007
- The nature and scope of global ethics and the relevance of theEarth CharterJournal of Global Ethics, 2005
- On the idea of a global ethicJournal of Global Ethics, 2005
- Beyond a Western Bioethics: Voices from the Developing WorldJournal of Medical Ethics, 2003
- Capability and Well‐Being1993
- The challenge of global ethicsJournal of Business Ethics, 1991