Euglena gracilis has an unusual photosystem I (PSI) with a small core flanked by up to 16 light-harvesting complex I (LHCI) subunits containing abundant long-wavelength ‘red’ chlorophylls. The combination of a large and red-shifted antenna can pose limitation on photochemical excitation trapping. We investigate the PSI light-harvesting function by time-resolved fluorescence, transient-absorption, two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy, and quantum dynamics calculations. The results show that despite an exceptionally large and spectrally broad antenna, the unique architecture of the Euglena PSI supercomplex achieves robust and near-optimal excitation trapping. LHCIs form a ‘spiderweb’ with fast inter-subunit excitation migration facilitated by distributed excitonic domains connecting low-energy states. Excitations from any LHCI reach the PSI core within several tens of picoseconds, mainly through strongly coupled LHCIs; however, dynamic disorder can activate additional parallel pathways. Thus, Euglena PSI reveals design principles for light-harvesting systems with extended absorption cross-section and spectral range.