A cross-national comparison of the quality of clinical care using vignettes
Open Access
- 27 July 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Health Policy and Planning
- Vol. 22 (5) , 294-302
Abstract
In studies comparing clinical practice to evidence-based standards, researchers have found that quality of care is inconsistently provided to different segments of the population in both developing and developed countries. To test the hypothesis that quality of care varies widely within different countries, we conducted a prospectively designed evaluation of quality for three common clinical conditions: diarrhoea, tuberculosis and prenatal care. Five countries participated in the study: China, the Philippines, Mexico, El Salvador and India. Within each country, physicians were randomly selected from tertiary care hospitals, district level hospitals, and public and private outpatient clinics. A total of 488 previously validated case vignettes were administered to 300 participating physicians. Vignettes were scored according to evidence and expert based quality criteria. We used a random effects model to estimate the associations between quality scores by case, physician characteristics, study site, and country. We found that average quality of care was low (61.0%), but there exists a wide variation in overall quality (30–93%). While there was little difference in average quality scores between countries (60.2 to 62.6%), variation within countries was broad. The wide variation was consistent across facility type, medical condition and domain of care. We also found that younger, female, tertiary care and specialist physicians performed better than their counterparts. We conclude that some physicians provide exceptional care even in the setting of limited resources. Furthermore, poor quality can be addressed by health policy planners by directing remediation toward the lowest performers.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quality of care and its impact on population health: A cross-sectional study from MacedoniaSocial Science & Medicine, 2006
- The Quality of Health Care Delivered to Adults in the United StatesNew England Journal of Medicine, 2003
- Risk and protective factors for two types of error in the treatment of children with fever at outpatient health facilities in BeninInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 2003
- Reliability associated with the abstraction of data from medical records for inclusion in an information system for persons with a traumatic brain injuryBrain Injury, 2002
- Reducing Infections Among Women Undergoing Cesarean Section in Colombia by Means of Continuous Quality Improvement MethodsArchives of internal medicine (1960), 2001
- Quality of hospital care for seriously ill children in less-developed countriesThe Lancet, 2001
- The policy implications of better structure and process on birth outcomes in JamaicaHealth Policy, 1998
- Effect of training on the clinical management of malaria by medical assistants in GhanaSocial Science & Medicine, 1996
- Factors influencing physicians' prescribing behaviour in the treatment of childhood diarrhoea: Knowledge may not be the clueSocial Science & Medicine, 1996
- Improving primary health care through systematic supervision: a controlled field trialHealth Policy and Planning, 1995