Comparison of False‐Positive Reactions in Direct‐Binding Anti‐HIV ELISA Using Cell Lysate or Recombinant Antigens
Authors:
- 1 October 1990
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Vox Sanguinis
- Vol. 59 (3) , 160-166
Abstract
In a 2‐year study of false‐positive anti‐HIV‐1 tests in blood donors at Manchester and Lancaster Blood Banks, the reactions associated with a HIV‐infected cell lysate antigen were compared with those using recombinant‐antigen‐based tests. In year 1 (cell lysate test) at Manchester BTS 0.21% of 119,178 donations were repeatedly reactive, compared with 0.53% of 119,004 donations in year 2 (recombinant antigen). Reactive sera were tested at Manchester PHL by three different immunoassays. Referred specimens were classified as anti‐HIV positive (95–100% reactive in all the assays), equivocal or negative (negative results in all three immunoassays). Two donors were confirmed to be anti‐HIV positive over the 2‐year period. Most sera were negative by confirmatory immunoassays in years 1 and 2. In year 1, a study of 60 referred sera with sex‐ and age‐matched controls showed high correlation between a reactive anti‐HIV‐1 screening test and indeterminate anti‐HIV‐1 patterns on Western blot showing reactions with HIV gag‐coded proteins. In year 2, less than 10% of referred sera were reactive by Western blot, and there was no correlation between a reactive screening anti‐HIV test, the strength of signal in the test or a reactive Western blot. Follow‐up showed that donors whose sera were reactive in years 1 and 2 by the anti‐HIV‐1 screening test formed almost two different populations. Four donors with equivocal anti‐HIV‐1 confirmatory tests had anti‐HIV ‘envelope’ reactions. The follow‐up of donors with equivocal confirmatory immunoassays on Western blot failed to show an increase in the strength of immunoassay reaction or Western blot reaction, with the possible exception of 1 donor with an anti‐HIV‐p24 reaction by Western blot. Most confirmatory testing can be done using immunoassays. The significance of the Western blot reactions needs further investigation.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Absence of HIV Infection in Blood Donors with Indeterminate Western Blot Tests for Antibody to HIV-1New England Journal of Medicine, 1990
- FOLLOWING UP INDETERMINATE HIV-1 WESTERN BLOTSThe Lancet, 1989
- Blood Donors with Indeterminate Anti-p24gagReactivity in HIV-1 Western Blot: Absence of Infectivity to Transfused Patients and in Virus CultureVox Sanguinis, 1989
- Beyond transcriptional eventsNature, 1989
- False-positive sera do not react with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)Gag-encoded recombinant antigenJournal of Medical Virology, 1989
- A new second-generation anti-HIV-1 enzyme immunoassay using recombinant envelope and core proteinsAIDS, 1988
- DONOR SCREENING FOR HIV: HOW MANY FALSE NEGATIVES?The Lancet, 1988
- Human immunodeficiency virus test evaluation, performance, and use. Proposals to make good tests betterJAMA, 1988
- Screening for HIV: Can We Afford the False Positive Rate?New England Journal of Medicine, 1987
- Follow-up testing of blood donors found to be enzyme immunoassay positive/Western blot negative for HTLV-III antibody1986