Public relations academics and practitioners face a risk-fraught future shaped by complex issues. A new paradigmatic and normative approach is needed to guide scholarly research as well as practice. We posit that the challenges practitioners and researchers face stem from public relations being led by modernism, excellence, and persuasion. To enable and empower practitioners and researchers to take on this challenge, we introduce the concept of tame, wicked, super wicked problems, and metamodernism as an epistemological bridge between binary modern and postmodern perspectives. Our proposed solutions would allow communicators to practice responsible persuasion, as well as to acknowledge the role of personal values in communication and to understand power distribution and relations.