Severity as a Priority Setting Criterion: Setting a Challenging Research Agenda
Open Access
- 22 May 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Care Analysis
- Vol. 28 (1) , 25-44
Abstract
Priority setting in health care is ubiquitous and health authorities are increasingly recognising the need for priority setting guidelines to ensure efficient, fair, and equitable resource allocation. While cost-effectiveness concerns seem to dominate many policies, the tension between utilitarian and deontological concerns is salient to many, and various severity criteria appear to fill this gap. Severity, then, must be subjected to rigorous ethical and philosophical analysis. Here we first give a brief history of the path to today’s severity criteria in Norway and Sweden. The Scandinavian perspective on severity might be conducive to the international discussion, given its long-standing use as a priority setting criterion, despite having reached rather different conclusions so far. We then argue that severity can be viewed as a multidimensional concept, drawing on accounts of need, urgency, fairness, duty to save lives, and human dignity. Such concerns will often be relative to local mores, and the weighting placed on the various dimensions cannot be expected to be fixed. Thirdly, we present what we think are the most pertinent questions to answer about severity in order to facilitate decision making in the coming years of increased scarcity, and to further the understanding of underlying assumptions and values that go into these decisions. We conclude that severity is poorly understood, and that the topic needs substantial further inquiry; thus we hope this article may set a challenging and important research agenda.Keywords
This publication has 97 references indexed in Scilit:
- Lifetime QALY prioritarianism in priority setting: quantification of the inherent trade-offCost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation, 2014
- Six Common Mistakes in Conservation Priority SettingConservation Biology, 2013
- CAN COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS INTEGRATE CONCERNS FOR EQUITY? SYSTEMATIC REVIEWInternational Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 2012
- Priority setting: what constitutes success? A conceptual framework for successful priority settingBMC Health Services Research, 2009
- Process Is the PointAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2008
- Priority setting in health care: Lessons from the experiences of eight countriesInternational Journal for Equity in Health, 2008
- The Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (WEMWBS): development and UK validationHealth and Quality of Life Outcomes, 2007
- Incompletely Theorized AgreementsHarvard Law Review, 1995
- Priority setting in public and private health careJournal of Health Economics, 1988
- Subjective well-being.Psychological Bulletin, 1984