Contrasting Visions: Identity, Literacy, and Boundary Work in a Fan Community
- 1 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in E-Learning and Digital Media
- Vol. 11 (6) , 619-632
Abstract
This article focuses on learning and identity-related practices of young female fans of a popular British boy band called One Direction . Drawing on qualitative inquiry into a fanfiction community formed around the band, analysis highlights (a) the literate work fans engage in, including writing, reading, critiquing, and collaborating on multimodal texts, (b) identity work performed by the fans with respect to what it means to be a true fan, a teen, and an effective writer within this community, and (c) ways in which the literate and identity work weave together to inform participation and identification in the One Direction fanfiction community, creating both links and ruptures between young people's out-of-school and in-school spaces. Analyses center on the ways the fans themselves define their involvement, with a focus on subgroup identities. Interview data highlight the ways fans used linguistic, technological, and social resources to stake out certain identities and to negotiate status within the site. Although power-laden dynamics defined community participation, fans felt ownership over their literacy and identity production practices, often drawing a contrast to school practices. We then discuss the meanings youth make of their fan practices and their contrastive experiences in fan and school spaces, connecting study findings to current debates on the import of pop culture in formal schooling.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Writing in the Wild: Writers’ Motivation in Fan‐Based Affinity SpacesJournal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2013
- Local Literacies2012
- Skate Perception: Self-Representation, Identity and Visual Style in a Youth Subculture2009
- New Audiences, New TextualitiesInternational Journal of Cultural Studies, 2003
- Play: The Reproduction and Resistance of Dominant Gender IdeologiesWorld Leisure Journal, 2003
- Interactional Ethnography: An Approach to Studying the Social Construction of Literate PracticesLinguistics and Education, 2000
- L2 Literacy and the Design of the Self: A Case Study of a Teenager Writing on the InternetTESOL Quarterly, 2000
- The narrative constitution of identity: A relational and network approachTheory and Society, 1994
- A Situated Perspective on What Counts as Reading1991
- ON FIELDWORKJournal of Contemporary Ethnography, 1989