Comparative accuracy and resolution assessment of two prototype proton computed tomography scanners
Authors:
Open Access
- 5 May 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 49 (7) , 4671-4681
Abstract
Background: Improving the accuracy of relative stopping power (RSP) in proton therapy may allow reducing range margins. Proton computed tomography (pCT) has been shown to provide state‐of‐the‐art RSP accuracy estimation, and various scanner prototypes have recently been built. The different approaches used in scanner design are expected to impact spatial resolution and RSP accuracy.Purpose: The goal of this study was to perform the first direct comparison, in terms of spatial resolution and RSP accuracy, of two pCT prototype scanners installed at the same facility and by using the same image reconstruction algorithm.Methods: A phantom containing cylindrical inserts of known RSP was scanned at the phase‐II pCT prototype of the U.S. pCT collaboration and at the commercially oriented ProtonVDA scanner. Following distance‐driven binning filtered backprojection reconstruction, the radial edge spread function of high‐density inserts was used to estimate the spatial resolution. RSP accuracy was evaluated by the mean absolute percent error (MAPE) over the inserts. No direct imaging dose estimation was possible, which prevented a comparison of the two scanners in terms of RSP noise.Results: In terms of RSP accuracy, both scanners achieved the same MAPE of 0.72% when excluding the porous sinus insert from the evaluation. The ProtonVDA scanner reached a better overall MAPE when all inserts and the body of the phantom were accounted for (0.81%), compared to the phase‐II scanner (1.14%). The spatial resolution with the phase‐II scanner was found to be 0.61 lp/mm, while for the ProtonVDA scanner somewhat lower at 0.46 lp/mm.Conclusions: The comparison between two prototype pCT scanners operated in the same clinical facility showed that they both fulfill the requirement of an RSP accuracy of about 1%. Their spatial resolution performance reflects the different design choices of either a scanner with full tracking capabilities (phase‐II) or of a more compact tracker system, which only provides the positions of protons but not their directions (ProtonVDA).Keywords
Funding Information
- Bayerisch-Kalifornischen Hochschulzentrum (A1[2018‐2])
- Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (388731804)
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- A stoichiometric calibration method for dual energy computed tomographyPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2014
- Experimental verification of ion stopping power prediction from dual energy CT data in tissue surrogatesPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2013
- Filtered backprojection proton CT reconstruction along most likely pathsMedical Physics, 2013
- Towards task-based assessment of CT performance: System and object MTF across different reconstruction algorithmsMedical Physics, 2012
- Comprehensive analysis of proton range uncertainties related to patient stopping-power-ratio estimation using the stoichiometric calibrationPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2012
- Range uncertainties in proton therapy and the role of Monte Carlo simulationsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2012
- Total variation superiorization schemes in proton computed tomography image reconstructionMedical Physics, 2010
- A more accurate reconstruction system matrix for quantitative proton computed tomographyMedical Physics, 2009
- A maximum likelihood proton path formalism for application in proton computed tomographyMedical Physics, 2008
- The calibration of CT Hounsfield units for radiotherapy treatment planningPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1996