Woman vs. Fetus: Frame Transformation and Intramovement Dynamics in the Pro-Life Movement
- 28 February 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Sociological Spectrum
- Vol. 34 (2) , 163-184
Abstract
What happens when insiders challenge a movement's dominant frame? To advance knowledge regarding how movement factions respond to frame transformation proposals, this paper examines an attempt to transform the central framing of the American pro-life movement. Over the past four decades, the American pro-life movement primarily employed a fetal rights frame. Yet a growing contingent of the pro-life movement is attempting to replace fetal-centric rhetoric with a frame claiming abortion is harmful to women. Using a combination of focus groups, interviews, and participant observation, this paper explains why this faction is challenging hegemonic pro-life framing and how more traditional pro-life actors respond. I argue that while ideological and organizational concerns often make transformation of a movement's central framing unlikely, if intramovement challengers can persuasively highlight the resonant appeal of challenging frames, movement colleagues are often willing to partially accommodate transformation requests by responding with frame extension.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Explaining Frame VariationSocial Problems, 2012
- Pro-Life, Pro-Woman? Frame Extension in the American Antiabortion MovementJournal of Women, Politics & Policy, 2011
- Heretical Social Movement Organizations and Their Framing Strategies*Sociological Inquiry, 2007
- Framing the Issue: Religion, Secular Ethics and the Case of Animal Rights MobilizationSocial Forces, 2006
- From Protective to Equal Treatment: Legal Framing Processes and Transformation of the Women’s Movement in the 1960sAmerican Journal of Sociology, 2006
- The Art of Reframing Political DebatesContexts, 2006
- Victory and Beyond: A Historical Comparative Analysis of the Outcomes of the Abortion Movements in Sweden and the United StatesSociological Forum, 2004
- When Frame Extension FailsJournal of Contemporary Ethnography, 2003
- Abortion as a Social Problem: The Construction of "Opposite" Solutions in Sweden and the United StatesSocial Problems, 1998
- Institutional Constraints on Social Movement "Frame Extension": Shifts in the Legislative Agenda of the American Federation of Labor, 1881-1955Social Forces, 1998