Comparing the cost‐effectiveness of drones, camera trapping and passive acoustic recorders in detecting changes in koala occupancy
Open Access
- 2 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 14 (7) , e11659
Abstract
Quantifying the cost‐effectiveness of alternative sampling methods is crucial for efficient biodiversity monitoring and detection of population trends. In this study, we compared the cost‐effectiveness of three novel sampling methods for detecting changes in koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) occupancy: thermal drones, passive acoustic recorders and camera trapping. Specifically, we fitted single‐season occupancy‐detection models to data recorded from 46 sites in eight bioregions of New South Wales, Australia, between 2018 and 2022. We explored the effect of weather variables on daily detection probability for each method and, using these estimates, calculated the statistical power to detect 30%, 50% and 80% declines in koala occupancy. We calculated power for different combinations of sites (1–200) and repeat surveys (2–40) and developed a cost model that found the cheapest survey design that achieved 80% power to detect change. On average, detectability of koalas was highest with one 24‐h period of acoustic surveys (0.32, 95% CI's: 0.26, 0.39) compared to a 25‐ha flight of drone surveys (0.28, 95% 0.15, 0.48) or a 24‐h period of camera trapping consisting of six cameras (0.019, 95% CI's: 0.014, 0.025). We found a negative quadratic relationship between detection probability and air temperature for all three methods. Our power and cost analysis suggested that 148 sites surveyed with acoustic recorders deployed for 14 days would be the cheapest method to sufficiently detect a 30% decline in occupancy with 80% power. We recommend passive acoustic recorders as the most efficient sampling method for monitoring koala occupancy compared to cameras or drones. Further comparative studies are needed to compare the relative effectiveness of these methods and others when the monitoring objective is to detect change in koala abundance over time.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perspectives in machine learning for wildlife conservationNature Communications, 2022
- A Comprehensive Overview of Technologies for Species and Habitat Monitoring and ConservationBioScience, 2021
- Real-time drone derived thermal imagery outperforms traditional survey methods for an arboreal forest mammalPLOS ONE, 2020
- Maximising camera trap data: Using attractants to improve detection of elusive species in multi-species surveysPLOS ONE, 2019
- Passive acoustics and sound recognition provide new insights on status and resilience of an iconic endangered marsupial (koala Phascolarctos cinereus) to timber harvestingPLOS ONE, 2018
- Passive acoustic surveys for predicting species’ distributions: Optimising detection probabilityPLOS ONE, 2018
- Failure to Respond to Food Resource Decline Has Catastrophic Consequences for Koalas in a High-Density Population in Southern AustraliaPLOS ONE, 2016
- Accuracy and efficiency of detection dogs: a powerful new tool for koala conservation and managementScientific Reports, 2015
- Accounting for Imperfect Detection in Ecology: A Quantitative ReviewPLOS ONE, 2014
- Activity Patterns of Free-Ranging Koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) Revealed by AccelerometryPLOS ONE, 2013