Abstract
This study examines whether the composite celebrity character of board directors predicts shareholder wealth maximization across all 503 S&P 500 constituent companies over April 2020 to April 2025. Drawing on upper echelons theory, signaling theory, and resource dependence theory, we construct a five-dimensional Celebrity Goodwill Score (CGS) operationalizing director credibility, goodwill, image, influence, and standard of value. An equalweighted Celebrity Company Index returns 163.9% versus 65.1% for the S&P 500 (Sharpe ratio 1.13 vs. 0.62). The OLS regression finds that the CGS (β = +0.44, p = 0.003) and the celebrity director count (β = +0.34, p = 0.036) significantly predict the five-year total shareholder return; binary celebrity presence does not (p = 0.111). Fama-French three-factor analysis yields an annualized Jensen's alpha of +7.44% (t = 2.35, p = 0.019). The matching of the propensity score preserves a TSR premium of 53 percentage points (p = 0.040). The results remain on a pre-COVID baseline from January 2019. The findings advance multitheory understanding of board human capital and carry direct implications for nominating committees and institutional investors.