Decision Considerations and Strategies for Lip Surgery in Patients with Cleft lip/Palate: A Qualitative Study
Preprint
Abstract
Objective: To qualitatively assess surgeons decision making for lip surgery in patients with cleft lip/palate (CL/P). Design: Prospective, non-randomized, clinical trial. Setting: Clinical data institutional laboratory setting. Patients, Participants: The study included both patient and surgeon participants recruited from four craniofacial centers. The patient participants were babies with a CL/P requiring primary lip repair surgery (n=16) and adolescents with repaired CL/P who may require secondary lip revision surgery (n=32). The surgeon participants (n=8) were experienced in cleft care. Facial imaging data that included 2D images, 3D images, videos, and objective 3D visual modelling of facial movements were collected from each patient, and compiled as a collage termed the Standardized Assessment for Facial Surgery (SAFS) for systematic viewing by the surgeons. Interventions: The SAFS served as the intervention. Each surgeon viewed the SAFS for six distinct patients (two babies and four adolescents) and provided a list of surgical problems and goals. Then an in-depth-interview (IDI) was conducted with each surgeon to explore their decision-making processes. IDIs were conducted either in person or virtually, recorded, and then transcribed for qualitative statistical analyses using the Grounded Theory Method. Results: Rich narratives/themes emerged that included timing of the surgery; risks/limitations and benefits of surgery; patient/family goals; planning for muscle repair and scarring; multiplicity of surgeries and their impact; and availability of resources. For diagnoses/treatments, surgeons agreed, and level of surgical experience was not a factor. Conclusions: The themes provided important information to populate a checklist of considerations to serve as a guide for clinicians.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Dermatology and Dermatitis, 8 (5), 01.
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding decision making about major surgery: protocol for a qualitative study of shared decision making by high-risk patients and their clinical teamsBMJ Open, 2020
- Decision-Making in Cleft-Related Surgery: A Qualitative Analysis of Patients and CaregiversThe Cleft Palate Craniofacial Journal, 2019
- Identifying Patient Characteristics Associated With Deficits in Surgical Decision MakingJournal of Patient Safety, 2016
- Shared Decision Making and Choice for Elective Surgical CareOtolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, 2015
- Clinical decision making: how surgeons do itAnz Journal of Surgery, 2013
- Shape Change Along Geodesics with Application to Cleft Lip SurgeryJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C: Applied Statistics, 2011
- Effects of Lip Revision Surgery in Cleft Lip/Palate PatientsJournal of Dental Research, 2010
- Children with Orofacial Clefts: Health-Care Use and Costs among a Privately Insured PopulationPublic Health Reports®, 2009
- How do surgeons make intraoperative decisions?Quality and Safety in Health Care, 2007
- The Extended Case MethodSociological Theory, 1998